Did you see Taare Zameen Par (subtitled) or Like Stars on Earth (dubbed)

Because that makes all the difference in the world. I've been scratching my head for a long time over all the hate that one of my most favourite movies has been getting, and I think I just may have hit upon the real reason. Guys, please clear this up for me. Did you see the subtitled one of the dubbed one, and then whether you liked it or not.