rubbish


I kinda liked idea of film makers to investigate DNA only to prove Jesus wasn't blood relative to Maria. Ha, ha. Why they didn't take DNA of that child and compared to DNA of Jesus? This documentary ir full sience fiction. If you are blind, you take it seriously. All prestigious academics had rejected this doc. For more details read Wikipedia. I am very disappointed Cameron was producer of this fiction. Yes, perhaps, he doesn't like that there can be another king of the world.

reply

"I kinda liked idea of film makers to investigate DNA only to prove Jesus wasn't blood relative to Maria."

The problem I had was since they were using mitochondrial DNA, which is passed from mother to child, how they can rule out that the Jesus and Mariame (which was the other DNA they tested, not Maria) weren't father and daughter?

"Ha, ha. Why they didn't take DNA of that child and compared to DNA of Jesus?"

Three reasons. One - they were only able to recover samples suitable for DNA extracting from the Jesus and Mariame ossuaries, if memory serves. Two - what would be the point? The ossuary clearly states that it contained Judah son of Jesus. There was one Jesus in the tomb. No question there. Three - again, mitochondrial DNA can only show mother-child relationships. There would be no matching between Jesus and Judah by definition. You and your father don't share the same mitochondrial DNA. Your MTdna would match your mother, however.


"This documentary ir full sience fiction."

I must have fallen asleep and missed the spaceships and laser beams.

"If you are blind, you take it seriously."

Well, on the strength of that vigorous debunking, and the obvious attention you were paying such that you understood what mitochondrial DNA is and that DNA could only be recovered from two ossuaries and what the labels on the ossuaries were, you've convinced me.


"All prestigious academics had rejected this doc. For more details read Wikipedia."

There's a lot of cautious academics not wanting to jump to conclusions (and get death threats). No one has disproven the core facts or logic behind the documentary. Not even you, shockingly enough.

" I am very disappointed Cameron was producer of this fiction."

Sir or madam, please learn the definition of "fiction", science or otherwise, before using it in a sentence in public.

"Yes, perhaps, he doesn't like that there can be another king of the world."

Maybe he's a man who supports the use of science and reason to form his opinions. And if Jesus is the King of the World, he's got a lot to answer for.

reply