Manoel de Oliveira segment


How was his segment? I'm curious to know what the oldest director in the world did in this film...

reply

His segment is one of the worst ones according to me - but I've always loathed anything related to Oliveira anyways. It's got Michel Piccoli standing for Kruchev (lol) and another fat guy standing for pope 12th or some other number. And the pope comes to kruchev and says "oh you're fat, like me" or something. It's got absolutely nothing to see with a cinema room, it's ugly, the actors are 143 years old, the event that is related is itself 143 years old, no one even remembers or cares to know who kruchev was or what there was to remember about pope 12th, it's forgotten as soon as you've seen it.
Here, hope it helped, I'm sorry if I can't be any more positive about this segment but it almost made me gag when compared to some of the most brilliant films.

reply

Very weak indeed. It's about a confrontation between fat bellies: Krutchev and Pope John the XXIIIth ones; communists and catholics. Krutchev is Michel Piccoli and the Pope is João Bénard da Costa,portuguese house cinema director. Pure nonsense.

reply

And it's filmed in black and white and it's a silent movie !! There's indeed no relation with a cinema theatre. But it was quite interesting... A funny(not very funny)piece of work by a 99 years old young man

"Dans la vie, il faut regarder par la fenêtre"
Eugène Ionesco

reply

I am not a fan of de Oliveira but enjoyed this bit of fluff. Too bad you don;t have patience for the past with the subject matter.
Saw the director having diner by himself at 1am in Cannes...though usually he has a beautiful young woman with him. That is what keeps him young?

reply

I see. Thanks for the info.

reply

It's not as bad as people here make it out to be, it is a satiric stab at the Pope.

"This is the head comrade for the Catholics, Pope John XXIII. [...] When Comrade Stalin told us to dance, didn't we dance? When Comrade Pope tells Catholics to pray, they all start praying."

reply

His one is the second worst I would say, at least better than the last Jew

reply

surprised to read this, for me it was one of the best! it was unbelievebly funny. you see classic Manoel de Oliveira and his heavy and slow and meaningful films, and then at about 100 he does this satyrical piece about the pope and communists and bellies... for me it's sheer genius!
get a sense of humour people. and of course it was about cinema - an hommage to silent film, and an hommage to the fun essential to movie making (which he quite clearly had making this non sense short).

anyway it's been a while what did you think of his segment?

reply