MovieChat Forums > Film Noir (2008) Discussion > How did he propose to GET the million?

How did he propose to GET the million?


I enjoyed watching this film.
The mood, the pace, the general storyline were all engaging.

BUT, the thing that bugged me the most was the whole 'had plastic surgery to get a million dollars' idea.

That made NO SENSE WHATSOEVER!

Sam Ruben is a private detective. Stern wants David Hudson dead because Hudson is blackmailing him. He will pay a million dollars for Hudson dead. Ruben cannot find David Hudson, so he has plastic surgery to look like Hudson.
What was his plan after that?
There isn't a plausible scenario that could play out AND let him walk away with Stern's money.

How did Ruben expect to collect the money? Surely Stern would only pay the money when he knew Hudson was dead. Unless he was a complete and utter FOOL.
Did Ruben do it because he wanted to give the money to someone else (that we weren't told about in the film)?

No-one on this board has been able to answer that question logically yet.

I would very much like someone to clear it up for me.

reply

The movie doesn't clearly explain this .... at one point, Ruben is about to explain to detective Riley in the hospital, when asked the question about "why he got the plastic surgery" but then stops when told about "Ruben's" death.

One possible way he could have used the surgery (without getting himself killed by Stern) is to have used it to infiltrate Hudson's circle of friends ... I mean, somehow fool them into thinking that he was actually Hudson, & in this way get a track of Hudson's movements?

reply

Yeah he used the plastic surgery to infiltrate Hudson's life and track him down, but that doesn't explain how he would collect the money from Stern.

I can see a couple possible explanations how Ruben could collect the money after delivering Hudson. He could get plastic surgery again and be made back into Ruben. Or he would just have Stern put the money into an account.

reply

@@SPOILER@@

My guess is he would try to infiltrate Hudsons life, as others have suggested, and try to locate where the DVD was hidden. He would then use it to blackmail Stern.

** I read the news today, oh, boy. **

reply