MovieChat Forums > The Merry Gentleman (2009) Discussion > possible spoiler - too many holes..

possible spoiler - too many holes..


pardon me if i missed something but there were a few things that seemed critical that were never explained..

Frank was a hit man but it was never mentioned who he worked for.
the reasons behind the murders we saw him commit were never revealed.
if he made his living as a hit man, why is he working in a taylors shop?
why was he suicidal? was it guilt stemming from the murders he committed or something else?

there may be a few other things i'm not thinking of right now but you get the point..

reply

This movie is much less of a plot-driven popcorn-fest, and much more of a character study - even if one of the leads reveal little about himself. As Kate told Logan: "I can see you're a very private man". Anyway, it's not an action adventure where motives are called for to explain the actions of the pro-/antagonists. It's rather the opposite of that.

Who Frank worked for, and why he killed some people, is NOT a central theme of the movie. It is about 2 persons who are caught in situations where they're not likely to connect with ANYBODY, connecting with each other for a little while. Knowing exactly who Logan worked for, and what his victims did "wrong", is simply not necessary to know. In fact, that would distract and then people would start IMDB threads and complain that the movie is "disjointed".

The premise is that he is a undercover hitman, who is not content with what he is doing any more. The rest is taken from there, and the spotlight falls on the character's reaction to an unexpected meeting with a woman who affects his life in a positive way.

Logan works in a tailor shop, because that is his cover. That makes him a "legitimate" presence in the town, a strategy professional hitmen should have. No real hitman is offing people on a continual basis. They need to have something else to do that appears to be perfectly normal, so as not to raise any suspicions.

He was suicidal because deep down, he was unhappy about his loneliness, and having no-one else to care for. We can work that out for ourselves at the way he goes about nurturing the new friendship with Kate. Deep down, that is what he craved in life, and he was simply tired of the distancing from affection that being a hitman calls for.

reply

Thank you for an excellent explanation, my thoughts exactly.

reply

Those are not plot holes. They're irrelevant questions. Who cares why he did the killings? It doesn't matter for the purposes of this story.


"I'll book you. I'll book you on something. I'll find something in the book to book you on."

reply

and you're getting your panties in a twist why?
of course they are relevent. it's called character development.

reply

Those elements are only necessary to you as you want to be spoon fed a clear story line.




reply

As jacowium observed, your points do not describe plot holes - you might feel frustrated by the lack of an explicit background story, but that is not the result of any deficiency in the plotting.

reply