Meh, I find the dub to be mediocre to moderately above average at best. I don't see why 4chan can honestly say "The Black Lagoon English dub is so good it caused the Japanese dub to cease existing."
The Yakuza arc was not so great. Ginji and Yukio's voice actors were pretty darn bad. Plus, the English dialogue ended up changing the script from the Japanese version:
1. The biggest offender was making Ginji fluent in English. In the Japanese dub, whenever Revy spoke to Ginji, her voice actor had to actually speak English. To American ears, this "Engrish" sounds hilarious and stupid, but it's a crucial part of characterization that Revy and Ginji DON'T UNDERSTAND EACH OTHER'S LANGUAGES. Unless they're about to get into a fight, which is a language anyone understands.
2. The Chinese dialogue was removed. Sometimes Shenhua will start talking in Mandarin when she's really getting into a fight, but the English translators couldn't be bothered to follow the script like this, and instead opted to turn everything into English.
3. The Russian dialogue was removed. In the initial episode when Balalaika is negotiating with the yakuza thugs, she calls up her subordinates and tells them to detonate a bomb. In the Japanese dub, she speaks to them in Russian. In the English dub, they couldn't bother to translate two lines into Russian and give it to Patricia Drake to read.
It happens again when the KGB loser running the Russian Mafiya's operations is killed by Ginji. When Ginji corners the guy in the restaurant, he starts begging for his life in Russian, which leads Ginji to comment something like, "You don't even speak Japanese. How pitiful." Unfortunately in the English version, all lines are changed to English and everyone magically understands each other.
There is really only one English voice I like. Mr. Chang, mainly because I feel his Japanese actor is too old for his character.
Roberta is a borderline case: she sounds more emotionally unstable in Japanese (particularly in Roberta's Blood Trail, for obvious reasons), but I also liked Tabitha St. Germain's portrayal as an emotionless girl.
reply
share