MovieChat Forums > Moonlight (2007) Discussion > Fleur de Lis episode - Huge Ripoff of Th...

Fleur de Lis episode - Huge Ripoff of The Conversation


Yes, I know it's just another vampire TV show. But there is a big difference between a show doing an hommage and a blatant rip-off.

The Fleur de Lis story/episode is a giant rip-off of Francis Ford Coppola's film THE CONVERSATION.

Things 'borrowed':

Long bit of Man and Married Woman strolling in a city square while being eavesdropped.

Eavesdropping only picking up bits and pieces of the conversation.

Audio scrubbed to pick up additional pieces of dialogue.

Concerns from the conversation that the married woman might be killed if her husband were to find out.

Man (awkwardly) that did the eavesdropping sharing the same elevator with the married woman.

Eavesdropper refusing to turn over the evidence of the wife's infidelity to the husband's MALE secretary and insisting he will only give it directly to the husband.

Please.

reply

Wow I've seen the Conversation but never made the connection, so it didn't bother me. Well, it was a good movie, so it was nice to see that plot in Moonlight. You know, plots on TV shows usually aren't that logical or interesting....and that's most TV shows. You honestly can't expect that much from a TV show that has to wind up a plot 45 minutes and also include characterization, humor and action all in the same 45 minutes. I wouldn't judge too harshly.

WATCH MY VIDEO - MICK - SECOND CHANCE
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Kcnex-A0O88

reply

I remember back when this episode first aired, it caught my boyfriend's attention and he laughed, "hey look, they're doing The Conversation!" And he proceeded to point out and explain all the parallels to me since I'd never seen it. He even said, "If they're sticking to it, then xyz is about to happen...", and then it did!

A flurry of discussion then ensued on this board, and I vaguely remember one lengthy post (perhaps from one of the writers?) that the intent was to pay homage to The Conversation, and then went on to describe a bunch of well thought-out/planned parallels that were - as Adam Duritz would say - "Very very meaningful."

Too bad the post is long gone. Although people had complaints about the purported plagiarism, the writeup seemed to provide insight or at least another viewpoint of the script and the choices that were made.

reply

Oh, I would have loved to read that. It' nice that they were paying homage because, yeah from Youtube you can see that some scenes are identical. Especially the scene where he is playing back the obscured recording and then clears up the audio. "He'd kill us if he got the chance."

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xSP2fO-wcTE&feature=related

Short trailer
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jRB4PuY31Bs&feature=related

WATCH MY VIDEO - MICK - SECOND CHANCE
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Kcnex-A0O88

reply