MovieChat Forums > Tuya de hun shi (2007) Discussion > Very beautiful and human film

Very beautiful and human film


I'm rather satisfied with what my compatriots picked to win the Golden Bear - I truly loved this film, the story, the characters, the cinematography, the way how this film looked real (at least to my Western eyes) without craving for effect or trying to baffle. A solid story, touching, but not sentimental, unfolds before the viewer and successfully manages to get us involved into the lives of people from a faraway place.

To me nothing is more fascinating than human beings and to learn about the differences in cultures, the wonderful diversity which is the greatest resource of mankind. Therefore Tuya and her family won my attention effortlessly; this was my third film set in Mongolia, but showed an aspect of life I wasn't familiar with: what happens to a family of stockbreeders when one person's manpower is omitted? Tuya tries to manage without her husband's help: doing the cooking, dealing with the herds, there are two kids, and every morning she has to ride for miles on her camel only for the daily water supply.

She could take the easy way out: get a divorce, leave Bater to his fate, move to town with her kids and remarry. But she loves her husband and feels responsible for him - but going on like she tried to is getting over her strength, and the entire family is at risk to end up in poverty as her health begins to fail. So she agrees with her husband that they will divorce and she'll remarry someone who will accept him in his house, too.

Her attempts to find a new husband who will accept her conditions is told with subtle humor which never diminishs the hardship and the emotional turmoil of the participants in this story; and the ending is quite a smart shift away from the two possibilities that come to mind naturally which I found quite admirable - even the director isn't taking the easy way out. This is what I'd call an honest film, the category of cinema that never fails to interest me.

Regards, Rosabel


reply

This film was amazing! I am very glad netflix had it on their instant play que and recommended it to me based on my previous selections. I am in love with this film.

Beyond the cultural difference, the film speaks to you. It crosses barriers and tells a beautiful story about love, hardship and survival.

reply

Srigby, same thing happened to me (Netflix recommending the film, and my being in love with it). Your last two sentences are right on target.

reply

Great review, Rosabel, for a wonderful film. It's too bad the word "unforgettable" has become so overused. This film has images that will forever stay in my mind.

reply

Absolutely wonderful little film. We both thoroughly enjoyed it and loved the insights it gave us into the culture, etc. Highly recommended !
(It's funny, I put this in my Netflix instant viewing over a year ago, kept pushing it back to watch something else I'd added since then - better late than never....this was worth the wait).




You've done some bad things, sweetie.

reply

[deleted]