MovieChat Forums > Doubt (2008) Discussion > How the fuck did Meryl Not win this osca...

How the fuck did Meryl Not win this oscar?


Probably her best role and lose to fucking Kate Winslet, HA!

They shouldve swept the awards and its truly pathetic that this wasnt even nominated for best director and film. Stupid winners this year and forgettable nominees.

reply

I 100% agree.

reply

She did give a better performance than Winslet.

I think they gave to Winslet because Streep has already won some Oscars before, and had been nominated for so many. Winslet was the fresher face.

reply

So it’s about youth, not talent.
Fking joke.

reply

Not necessarily youth. It's more based on who the Academy feels is "due" for a win.

Streep had already won a few Oscars before. Winslet had never won any. The Academy just felt they had to reward Winslet with a win moreso than Streep as a result.

reply

Because she chews the scenery of every movie she has ever been in. I get so sick of her over stylized over acting. And so aware of her acting, rather than engaged in the character.

reply

2008 was a bad year over all for the Oscars

Best Actor should have been Mickey Rourke
Best Actress --- I'm good with Winslet, none were very good
Best Supporting Actor Should have been Hoffman or Downey
Best Supporting Actress should have been Amy Adams or Melissa Tomei
Best Director should have been --- NONE of the Nominated were very good much less BEST

reply