MovieChat Forums > Jimmy Carter Man from Plains (2008) Discussion > Mediocre President, Great Former Preside...

Mediocre President, Great Former President


The general consensus among unbiased historians is that Jimmy Carter was a mediocre president. The fiercest of his opponents always tried to make his period in office look like a complete failure. This does Carter a great injustice. He was a decent, socially concerned, somewhat moralizing man. His presidency met with a hopeless economic climate, and it’s unlikely a Republican would have made better job of it. His administration came with decent legislation, but had trouble getting it trough Congress. As far as foreign policy is concerned, Carter had some huge personal successes, including enduring peace between Egypt and Israel. Nevertheless just as often, he also acted hesitant and ambivalent.

After being voted out of office and a relative young age, 56 years old, Carter became one of the most energetic and highly regarded former U.S. Presidents ever. As head of the Carter-centre he travelled over the world to promote peace, human rights and development aid. For this he was awarded the Nobel Peace Price in 2000. The role of moral and authoritative elder statesman obviously suited Carter better, than the office of the President.

reply

Hear, hear. Yes, Carter was unfortunately not a great President. He was not a devious little schemer like Nixon before him or Reagan after him, and he came into power at an unlucky juncture. Carter is a great man nonetheless. It is sad that his time in office is so resoundingly denounced and derided by conservatives the world over. Unlike Reagan after him he did have some moral superiority and did care about the less priveleged and less well off in American society.

He was not the President for the smug middle and upper classes - like Reagan was. I have much more to say on this issue, but I think overall; God bless Carter, he is a good man and did change some things for the better.

reply

I give Carter enormous credit for securing peace between Israel and Egypt, and for courageously pardoning the Vietnam draft dodgers when nobody else would. Really, much of the bad stuff that happened during his presidency was beyond his control: the Iran hostage crisis, the flat economy, and the expensive oil costs that resulted from Iran cutting off oil shipments. It's too bad nobody listened to him when he gave his "Crisis of Confidence" speech, which is actually very pertinent about our energy problems today.

To me, LBJ, Nixon, Ford and Carter were all potentially good men whose presidencies failed because they tried to be too moderate. LBJ tried to be conservative with Vietnam; Nixon tried to be liberal with healthcare, China trade, and ending the war; Ford tried to be liberal by attempting detente with the Soviets; and Carter tried to be conservative by ordering Operation Eagle Storm (the failed rescue mission to save the hostages) and by considering implementing a military draft. Then of course we got Reagan, and suddenly it's partisan politics in the White House all over again.

Loved this film, by the way. I'm not sure if I agree with Carter's accusation that Israel is guilty of forcing "apartheid" on Palestine... but then again I've never been to the West Bank.

Bravo, Jonathan Demme.

"What I don't understand is how we're going to stay alive this winter."

reply