MovieChat Forums > Kirschblüten - Hanami (2008) Discussion > I got confused half way through... (spoi...

I got confused half way through... (spoilers)


I somehow confused myself over which of them was diagnosed at the beginning. When the wife died unexpectedly, i managed to convince myself that the diagnoses scene was ambiguous and it was never explicit in which of them was ill.

My first reaction when the wife dies was: "oh great predictable plot twist". Then i thought about it a bit and was excited because i thought maybe i missed something in the first scene.

Up till that point the whole movie works with either of them being the one with the illness. Either the wife is not telling the husband he will die, or she is the one with the illness and is hiding it from him.

After going back and viewing the first scene again i was wrong, and it clearly says that the husband was ill. But to me it would have been great if that scene could really have been made ambiguous. I like it when a movie is clever enough to fool you convincingly for a whole hour.

I wonder if that first scene could be scripted to make it convincing that either one could be dying, or hint at one but not be clear. Anyone else think it would work well like that?

So unfortunately it didn't fool me and was just an oh-the-one-you-didn't-expect-to-die-died plot twist. But even so it was still a very good film plenty of unusual scenes and realism more convincing than most.

Just a couple of the shots were very amateurish and dropped me out of the experience (mainly in second half in Japan for some reason), but that's a minor complaint and the rest of the movie more than makes up for them.

reply

I also felt some of the shots were amateurish in the second half but it didn't put me off too much.

For the diagnosis at the start the doctors did say explicitly that it was the husband. So you must've just missed that part as it was at the very start and only a sentence or so.

Given that, I don't agree that it was predictable. I thought it was a good, surprising plot twist and I view myself as being someone who sees plot twists coming a mile off.

Loved the movie anyway and the direction and realism of the shooting was great. The way the kids talked about the parents in particular really bought the film down to earth in a good way.

The ending was a bit funny with the 18 year old girl travelling around with the husband. It was a bit unrealistic and felt tacked on. The dancing was boring too but of course it was part of the films message and was necessary for that reason.

reply

I thought the dancing was powerful, and I had never seen it before.

reply

"The ending was a bit funny with the 18 year old girl travelling around with the husband. It was a bit unrealistic and felt tacked on. The dancing was boring too but of course it was part of the films message and was necessary for that reason."

So Trudi's lifelong passion, her secret dream, that which constituted her *very last living thought*, and through which Rudi was able to "reach" her again was "boring".

Holy cow, man.

reply

I just finished watching this movie after stumbling across it. I missed the part where he and his wife were in Germany and instead came in when he arrived in Tokyo. I had no idea that the husband was sick but I still saw it coming as soon as he went to visit Mt. Fuji w/ Yu. The scene with them looking for the mountain everyday I was like "Oh great... when the mountain finally shows itself he's going to die! :(" Anddddd he did. I'm kind of glad that I missed the very beginning now though as I was able to enjoy the story without constantly wondering when he was going to croak which is how I usually am when I know a character is terminally ill.


I found some pieces to be amateurish as well. I didn't much care for a lot of the scenes where he was roaming around the city. When he kept running into the seedy places I just felt awkward (I guess like he did though so maybe those scenes worked in making us feel like he might have felt?). Kind of made me wonder what sort of neighborhood his son moved to! lol

I do think the way they worked his death was beautiful though. I loved that dancing and the inclusion of his wife... like her spirit had come to him to dance with him one last time and then take him to the next life. Very powerful.

reply