MovieChat Forums > The Broken (2008) Discussion > A totally other perspective on 'The Brok...

A totally other perspective on 'The Broken', different twisted meaning


Heya..I had to watch This movie 2 times, When after some serious thinking, come to Think, That everything we see, from the very start, is Lena Headey (Gina), twisted inner thoughts. First of all WHY these visions/Dreams , where ITS distorded and the picture she find With her father and herself, where the fathers eyes n mouth is scratch . Here I like to come With my own and from my psychology studies point of wiew, a Common consequence of incest is That, sometimes after a trauma, The "victim", Gina., carcrash could bring back some fragments from The childhood, If a person has experienced abuse AS a child, they often cut or scratch The assault persons Face, often eyes and mouth away, because ITS a very painful memory. Soooo.... My point is That everything we AS wiever see in That movie, is something inside Gina's mind, twisted and deranged, and This is WHY so many (including myself) was extremely confused With This movie, because NOTHING , makes sense whatsoever.. From The start to end. I love (sometimes hate) movies dont make sense in Any f.... Lvl. Thats WHY I Think, ITS all in Gina's head, because she realize and suddenly Remember fragments, and see and Dream so distorded AS she does, I have made a "short" list below With questions and frustration, AS we all have. And last of all an applause to #SeanEllis #LenaHeadey #BestPsychologicalThrillerForALongTime #LikeForLike#FollowForFollow #Art #MarilynManson #TheLadyOfEternerty #Horror #Thriller #Congratulation

1: WHY do they talk about a broken mirror is a sign of bad luck?
2: WHY Don't they all "seems" cool With The total creepy Fact, That a mirror just Fall Down, shatters?
3: WHY doesn't Ginas red car seems NOT totally broken, When we in The accident see That The front glass in The car is broken, in every Way The car dont Seem so smashed AS it suppose to?
4: WHY does everyone act totally OUT of context? And their behavior weird in every Way?
5: WHY is The photo she find, destroyed? And WHY is her fathers eyes and mouth scratched? ( MOST IMPORTANT QUESTION IN THE WHOLE MOVIE...
6: Also important... WHY does she suddenly Call Down, after finding herself murdered by herself ( also a sign of assault from midtby parentes)(When One had been assaulted they often blame themselfes and want to kill themselfes), WHY is she suddenly Call Down and go to The window, and see her father watching her??

Well.. Thits it for now. But it could be an explanation to all That crazy Stuff going on, and If I must ( and I really do) , myself Think That it is a confident and plausible ( and If I might say... Genius) Way to come near a form of explanation to it all..??
Do you Think Im totally OFF here or??? Love to hear both positive and negative/hateful comments, come and join The PARRRTTYYY???
PeaceNLove Michella TheGoddess ( name on my Facebook profile) , and before someone feel whatever about my name TheGoddess, I just wanna say ALL women Are GODDESS'es, maybe Im....... ???

reply