If they are pirates ...
If they are pirates, why hasn’t anyone tried any dirty tricks yet? For instance, this past week when they had to row from one island to another for the next clue, I would have liked to see them set the other boat adrift as they set out on their way. Or they could have ripped the first clue out of the box rather than just trying to rehide it.
What made Rupert lovable on Survivor? When he stole all the shoes in the first episode! What’s wrong with these pirates?