MovieChat Forums > Breaking Bad (2008) Discussion > Jesse and self-acceptance

Jesse and self-acceptance


Do you buy the counselor's approach that addicts can't change or shouldn't judge themselves and have to learn self-acceptance to keep from repeating the spiral? Like everything's zen and "I'm OK, you're OK?" I thought it made sense in No Mas when he told the story of how he ran over his own daughter, but his philosophy was ridiculous in Rapid Dog when Jesse told the group the only reason why he was there was to sell them meth and he asked the leader if he was cool with that.

reply

Acceptance doesn't mean approval. Jesse didn't appreciate the difference.

The counselor accepted who he was and what he'd done, warts and all. It's fundamental to such programs to take an honest inventory of oneself, sparing nothing, the good the bad and the ugly. But that's not the same thing as approving.

So when Jesse provoked the counselor by saying, somewhat disingenuously, that he was "only" there to sell the group meth, and the counselor replied that he wasn't "ok" with it, that didn't mean he was, or had ever been, "ok" with killing his child.

The purpose of therapy is to help facilitate change deep inside because that's the only way to achieve lasting change. The counselor admits hating himself for a long time, but "it didn't stop me from drinking and getting high. It just made it that much worse." So there wasn't deep change, even though he'd done something so horrific.

Guilt is a useful signal telling us we need to change, but when it becomes a fixation it's just another form of addiction. It's no longer a motivation for change, and instead it destroys that desire and reinforces the same destructive state of mind. Self-hate is a tag-team partner. If you're listening to these signals over and over you can't hear others, or conceive different thoughts, which might have a beneficial effect on you, and on those with whom you share your life. But again, acceptance does not mean approval.


"You must not judge what I know by what I find words for." - Marilynne Robinson

reply

Acceptance doesn't mean approval.


I want to think that's an overreaching theme of the show. Because what you just described with the Group Leader could easily be describing Walt's plotline.

reply

In other words, you have to accept it as a pst mistake from which you hopefully learned and won't repeat. That doesn't mean you approve it, you will live with it the rest of your life knowing that what you did wasn't okay. But in other hands, you shouldn't stop yourself from trying to move forward and make a better future.

A nuance Jesse obviously didn't make. His stubbornness was one of the things that really pissed me off with his character.

reply