MovieChat Forums > The Road (2009) Discussion > I assume it was s nuclear bomb?

I assume it was s nuclear bomb?


But if so, why no radiation sickness? I know the book didn't allude to the reason of the disaster, but a nuclear bomb is all that makes sense.

reply

Well...as has been discussed in a number of other threads there are quite a few other explanations as to what caused the carnage, which includes but is not limited to:

- Supervolcano(s).

- Asteroid Strike.

- Nuclear conflict.

- Climate Change


I personaly like to think of the disaster as something not explicitly expalined for the reason that it doesn't NEED to be explained. Great writers such as J.G Ballad presented us with great global horrors and such apocolypses are not the focus because that isn't the point of the story.

reply

Climate change, certainly, but as a result of something else - whatever happened, was very sudden and cataclysmic. The leading theories, at least to my understanding, are asteroid strike or a super volcano. There's actually precedent to show this as a possibility:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Extreme_weather_events_of_535%E2%80%93536


My name is Gladiator - Maximus Decimus Meridius

reply

They would all be dead of radiation sickness.

"Is that your IQ or the number of dipwads your mother had?" - Car Pool Man

reply

...but a nuclear bomb is all that makes sense.


How is that all that makes sense?

I was always under the impression (mostly from the descriptions in the book) that it was something like a super volcano.

reply

The old man talks about signs and no-one believing them before it happened. I don't believe in God, but the way they talk about Him all through the film and the fact that Papa is so weirdly spiritual (a bit born again) makes me think this is like a rapture event.

Still I think it's good that the cause of the end isn't mentioned.


(Done with fish.)

reply

I believe that the post apocalyptic enviroment was caused by an escaped anaconda.

reply

Didn't they say there was a burst followed by a series of concussions?

reply

"Didn't they say there was a burst followed by a series of concussions?"

"There was a long shear of bright light, then a series of low concussions." To me, that implies a meteor streaking across the night sky, followed by the aftershocks of impact.

reply

I don't think it was a nuclear strike, but who knows.
The reason is that everything is dead, but there doesn't seem to be nuclear fallout.

not a super volcano either. The earth is too old and cooled off too much for a volcano to cause worldwide death.

Also there are earthquakes now. I don't think a nuclear war would cause an increase in earthquakes.

An asteroid strike is possible though. this would wipe out 99% of life on earth like it did when one killed the dinosaurs. Would explain why there is no plant life left and no sun. its blocked out by the debris in the atmosphere.
and a large one like that would upset and add stresses to the moving plates of the earths surface creating the geological disturbances seen in the movie as the not uncommon earthquakes.

reply

Yellowstone is due to erupt again and keep in mind we only see the USA in this movie so it is possible that at the very least a solid chunk of the continent is under a volcanic Ash cloud, the book makes it clear about there being ash but my guess is budget reasons probably didn't let it translate to film.

reply

The asteroid/comet strike is the likely contender of what happened, it most likely struck on the other side of the world or in the ocean in between to explain why the American continent wasn't obliterated.

reply

The asteroid/comet strike is the likely contender of what happened, it most likely struck on the other side of the world or in the ocean in between to explain why the American continent wasn't obliterated.
That by far would be number one on the "hit" list. And regardless what it was there was no doubt that head south made the most sense. Would like to think that the boy and his new caretakers found a boat and kept in that direction.

reply

No mention of war or fallout. The father mentions light in the sky, a series of loud concussions and fires over the horizon. So a series of large meteor-strikes. And a nuclear bomb couldnt have done this. A full out nuclear war could, but my first sentence makes that an unlikely culprit.

reply