The Iraqi people......


What's up with the Iraqi people?

Like in these bomb diffusing scenes, they don't seem to get out of the way of danger unless they get a gun shoved in their face, even if it's for their own safety.

The guy in the first scene tries to start a conversation with Sanborn during an intense operation in progress. Is he a terrorist, or is he just a complete moron?

And the taxi driver, what the hell was his problem?

Do these people need to be shouted at, and have a gun in their face before they listen?

reply

Some of them...yes.

Theyre used to violence, threats, etc...

reply

Theyre used to violence, threats, etc...


Sad, but true. They live in a warzone.

reply

And all thanks to the US.

reply

Wrong *beep* Don't speak of things you have no clue about. Go and read a history book to learn how the state of Iraq was created and what it meant for all the people that didn't want to be an "Iraqi" (an artificial identity which is same as Arab).

reply

It's a work of fiction.
I'd say this movie gives a biased account of Iraqi people.
Most ordinary people, no matter what part of the world, would be terrified in the presence soldiers waving around big guns.
Most of the Iraqis featured in the movie were terrorists or terrorist sympathizers. That's not an accurate representation of the actual Iraqi population, it's supposed to be a very small percentage.

"MALLL NOOO, JESUS CHRIST!" - Leonardo DiCaprio, Inception

reply

good answer, that helps. It's the impression I got both times with this film.

I couldn't believe there would be so many open sympathizers willing to risk their safety during all the obviously dangerous events. Surely most civilans would try to take cover in the risks. The first scene when the Iraqi comes up to chat - that did look to be a portrayal of how the insurgents often tried to interfere with ops.

But the taxi driver scene - that was strange, because you knew he understood from the beginning that he should get out. When he refused to move, by acting ignorent, the army should have proceeded as if this were a suicide bomber, but they did not. They stayed right up close to the car.

Maybe they were going to drag him out to see if he was wired, had a detonator, unsure. This probably showed the impossible dilemmas the EOD teams faced. Has there been further explanation from the filmakers on this scene?

reply

Good, i was about to think they're all terrorists or sympathizers.

The increase in human knowledge is the cause of the decline of religions.

reply

Most ordinary people, no matter what part of the world, would be terrified in the presence soldiers waving around big guns.


I remember reading the exact opposite. Troops in Iraq learned that pistols were a more effective means of intimidation because the Iraqi people had lived their entire lives with "soldiers waving around big guns" or owned the same "big guns" themselves. Pistols however were used by the Baathists as a means of execution and had a much bigger emotional impact.

reply

Is it so hard to imagine the country you were born in, and known all your life (US? UK?...?) is *INVADED* and completely taken over by Communist Chinese troops. The ChiComs haven't bothered to learn 3 words of English, but instead expect YOU to understand life-and-death orders shouted in Mandarin Chinese... you ARE fluent in Mandarin, are you not?

The ChiComs drive everywhere, like maniacs, at *high-speed* in *heavy* vehicles, running over and/or shooting anyone who even astronomically-remotely might maybe kinda possibly be a minor threat (i.e. driving within 100 yards IN A DENSE URBAN ZONE!), and suffer zero legal consequences for such daily murders...

Now pretend you're a man in this MEDIEVAL post-apocalypse world brought upon you by the Chinese, a MAN with half a testicle left... how would YOU behave towards your incredibly arrogant, openly racist Chinese overlords??? Invite them for tea?

Tell us, you quisling, I really want to know.

reply

Well good thing that's not going to happen, because we won't let any invader on our soil. They wouldn't make it long enough to get the armor on the ground.

reply

Actually what was most unrealistic about the movie was the choice of targets. Just about every single bomb they encountered targeted US soldiers in some way.

In reality, 80% of all bombings in Iraq were targeted at civilians. There was a civil war between the two religious factions going on that killed over ten times the number of people that died due to US forces.

reply

it's a filthy american propaganda implying that arabs deserve to be killed even when they do nothing and because they do nothing, perfect american racism.

reply

[deleted]

wow what a coincidence, my ex british boss name was darren, he was a piece of crap.

reply

If your stupid middle-eastern countries would get their heads from their assess and had proper government etc. Maybe you didn't so much guiding in how to live and not trying to kill everyone all the time.

reply

So you say that all Arab/Muslims are murderers want to kill non-Muslims
That's stupid and racist as fuq

reply


I will tell you, every damn Iraqi citizen scared the $hit out of me every time we were on patrol. They would all stare at you with the blazing hatred. Hearing them talk to each other and looking at you makes you so damn paranoid. An insurgency has that advantage to blend in with the people. You pretty much had to look at all of them like the enemy because a lot of them would have killed you if they could. We were not once warned about an IED or ambush. See this is the problem. They work with us and the insurgents would kill their families. They work with the insurgents and they would feel our wrath. I did not think about it till I was home for good. But I finally realized how much it had to have sucked to be an Iraqi citizen.


Haters gonna hate

reply

Hey there,

I saw in the movie that they had a sign on their Humvee saying if you come within 100 metres from the vehicles you will be shot, did you have to fire any warning shots or 40mm smoke grenades?

If you're not willing to give up everything, you've already lost

reply


Absolutely. Dozens of times. A very popular tactic for the insurgents was driving a car bomb up to our vehicles and blowing themselves up. It was all too common. We fired warning shots first. If they kept coming we tried to take out the engine and finally we would use lethal force if they did not stop. We had to use lethal force one time but luckily it was someone trying to blow us up and not an innocent civilian. A lot of troops I knew were forced to use lethal force and some innocent people were killed. Fighting insurgents is a messy war that usually end up with innocent people being killed most often.


Haters gonna hate

reply

We had to use lethal force one time but luckily it was someone trying to blow us up and not an innocent civilian.


What proof did you have that it was a VBIED? What type of explosives or ordnance did you find in his vehicle? Even though the sign is in English and Arabic I've heard that a lot of Iraqis are illiterate so some might not know about the "100 metre rule" written on your sign.

Doesn't that just piss you off that in the movie the supposed car bomber breaks several containment lines with armed soliders and makes in ALL THE WAY up to the protagonist of the film in a bomb suit carrying only his M9? Usually he would have been dead several hundred metres back up the road and not even a warning shot was fired?!

If you're not willing to give up everything, you've already lost

reply


C-4 connected with propane tanks with old Iraqi Army artillery shells that were to be remotely triggered by cell phone. We were lucky that the man jumped the gun a little early, actually hitting another car. Without hearing that by the time we would have noticed he would have been more than close enough to detonate. At that range with what he had, all 5 of us would have been killed along with quite a few civilians. See thats the thing, these bombs have killed MANY more Iraqi's than us. Although, IED's were the #1 thing that killed most of the coalition soldiers.

See, people need to understand how paranoid and suspicious of the civilians these IED's and constant ambushes made us. We have caught both Male and females planting the IED or even children. Some did it because they hated us. Some did it because they were paid to, and what we really started to discover, and this led us to turning the war around, was that Al Qaeda was kidnapping family members and threatening people to plant IED's. Some were forced to wear suicide bombs. Even mentally disabled people would have bombs strapped on them. These attacks killed more Muslims than anything and finally in 2007 we had the Sunni Awakening, which helped us decimate Al Qaeda because the Sunnis joined us finally and we also paid them. I was in Iraq because of the SURGE and this happened at the very end of my tour. But what I was getting at when I started this paragraph off is that the constant state of readiness you had to have for an enemy that as invisible really messes with your mind. You are alert 24-7 every damn day for over a year and since I have been home I have had trouble sleeping that that was 5 years ago. See this is how civilian massacres happen. Soldiers go out of their minds and start killing innocent people. I am not condoning it but people dont understand that concept. Sorry to get off track. I actually post on IMDb mainly late at night because I cant sleep and it relaxes me.

I should also clarify that even though is says stay back 100 meters or you will be shot, we were pretty much told to not engage them unless they were aggressively coming at you at a much closer range. Our CO's made us do everything possible to avoid civilian deaths because in a war with insurgents you must win the hearts and minds of the people. Yeah about the literate Iraqis, I would say I heard about a dozen times where innocent people did not realize it was a checkpoint and we shot. My best friend in the service did that very thing and believe me, it haunts him to this day. Yeah, 9 out of 10 times that guy who blew through the checkpoint would have been killed no doubt. It did not bother me because almost everything portrayed in the movie is false. The only thing that was really true and right was the atmosphere and the look of Iraq and the bond you share with your fellow soldiers. You serve anywhere?




Haters gonna hate

reply

C-4 connected with propane tanks with old Iraqi Army artillery shells that were to be remotely triggered by cell phone. We were lucky that the man jumped the gun a little early, actually hitting another car.


F.ck me and quoting Keanu from Speed "that's enough to put a hole in the world" lol

See thats the thing, these bombs have killed MANY more Iraqi's than us. Although, IED's were the #1 thing that killed most of the coalition soldiers.


That's the sad part of this war in that these insurgents are willing to trade 10 of their lives just to get 1 US/Coalition personnel. Moreover they are so indiscriminate in who they blow up and I don't know how they can sleep at night knowing they have killed a mother with her babies as collateral damage.

I'm not a bigot but there is no place on Earth for Islamic extremists and fundamentalists who want to turn society and women rights back to the Stone Age and live under the barbaric Sharia Law! I can't want for the day when the oil runs dry and/or other technologies take out the Western world's reliance on crude oil. Just like was said in Body of Lies the Middle East will return to the Stone Age with no economy.

But what I was getting at when I started this paragraph off is that the constant state of readiness you had to have for an enemy that as invisible really messes with your mind. You are alert 24-7 every damn day for over a year and since I have been home I have had trouble sleeping that that was 5 years ago.


I understand what you're saying, you've just gone from a YEAR of CONSTANTLY checking roof tops for snipers, turning around all the time thinking somebody is following you and watching your 6, mortars landing inside the Green Zone if you were ever there or your FOB etc? Then you return home and I don't care what anybody says you simply can't just turn off perpetually being at at high state of readiness all the time. Unfortunately at lot of men eat their guns because of PTSD.

How is your Veteran Affairs Department, have they helped you out in any way, maybe access to a psychologist/counsellor? Our VA Dept is top notch but then again we only had a couple of the 1000 troops at any one stage rather than you guys with tens of 1000s of military personnel in Afghanistan and Iraq over the 10 years...

I should also clarify that even though is says stay back 100 meters or you will be shot, we were pretty much told to not engage them unless they were aggressively coming at you at a much closer range.


What was your ROE, were you allowed to fire warning shots over their heads or was that too hostile and the possibility of hitting something or someone in the background?

It did not bother me because almost everything portrayed in the movie is false


That must piss you off that movie makes up so many things in the movie that don't happen in real life. People must says to you that "so that's what it's like in Iraq for EOD or infantry"? When it makes their are so many erroneous scenes, dialogue and down right scenarios going against Standard Operating Procedures that it is embarrassing. The only one good thing you pointed out is where they filmed in Jordan looks like Iraq.

You serve anywhere?


I'm only an Australian Army Reservist with the 4th/3rd Battalion, The Royal New South Wales Regiment.

http://www.army.gov.au/Who-we-are/Divisions-and-Brigades/Forces-Comman d/2nd-Division/5th-Brigade/4th_3rd-Battalion-The-Royal-New-South-Wales -Regiment

I have had a mate serve in the Royal Australian Armoured Corps in Iraq providing escort in ASLAVs https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ASLAV for VIP transport such as Diplomatic personnel in a convoy along "Route Irish", the road from Baghdad to the Green Zone, he had several contacts in his 7 month deployment from small arms fired luckily not from an RPG-7 which would destroy the ASLAV.


All our conventional troops pulled out by the end of last year leaving only our Special Operations Task Group (SOTG) which is our SASR and 1st/2nd Commando Regiments. Even when we had our conventional troops over there unless you were say a "Commando, Military Police, Fuel Specialist, Signals Corps Officer, Medical or Nursing Officer to name a few then no general infantry reservist is going to be deployed to either Afghanistan or Iraq.

However I have however participated in Exercise Talisman Saber which was a great experience cross training with the Yanks:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Exercise_Talisman_Saber



If you're not willing to give up everything, you've already lost

reply



F.ck me and quoting Keanu from Speed "that's enough to put a hole in the world" lol


Oh there would have been massive casualties. We are talking dozens and dozens of Iraqi Citizens deaths, the 5 of us, and hundreds of injuries. At first we suspected that this man had done this against his will. He could have blown the car by hand which would have been much easier and much more likely to go off. However in our report we concluded that had he done it against his will, the person with the cell phone trigger would have still blown it anyways and killed as many as possible. Who knows? The insurgents had unlimited explosives as during the 2003 invasion dozens of Saddams weapons sites were unguarded until it was to late.


That's the sad part of this war in that these insurgents are willing to trade 10 of their lives just to get 1 US/Coalition personnel. Moreover they are so indiscriminate in who they blow up and I don't know how they can sleep at night knowing they have killed a mother with her babies as collateral damage.

I'm not a bigot but there is no place on Earth for Islamic extremists and fundamentalists who want to turn society and women rights back to the Stone Age and live under the barbaric Sharia Law! I can't want for the day when the oil runs dry and/or other technologies take out the Western world's reliance on crude oil. Just like was said in Body of Lies the Middle East will return to the Stone Age with no economy.



Haters gonna hate

reply


F.ck me and quoting Keanu from Speed "that's enough to put a hole in the world" lol


Oh there would have been massive casualties. We are talking dozens and dozens of Iraqi Citizens deaths, the 5 of us, and hundreds of injuries. At first we suspected that this man had done this against his will. He could have blown the car by hand which would have been much easier and much more likely to go off. However in our report we concluded that had he done it against his will, the person with the cell phone trigger would have still blown it anyways and killed as many as possible. Who knows? The insurgents had unlimited explosives as during the 2003 invasion dozens of Saddams weapons sites were unguarded until it was to late.


That's the sad part of this war in that these insurgents are willing to trade 10 of their lives just to get 1 US/Coalition personnel. Moreover they are so indiscriminate in who they blow up and I don't know how they can sleep at night knowing they have killed a mother with her babies as collateral damage.

I'm not a bigot but there is no place on Earth for Islamic extremists and fundamentalists who want to turn society and women rights back to the Stone Age and live under the barbaric Sharia Law! I can't want for the day when the oil runs dry and/or other technologies take out the Western world's reliance on crude oil. Just like was said in Body of Lies the Middle East will return to the Stone Age with no economy.


Those very reasons are why the Sunni's, who were allied with Al Qaeda and responsible for most of the violence, finally realized that Al Qaeda was the one doing all the damage, not the coalition. When that happened everything changed. You know, knowing the war was bogus as there were no WMD's, you know what that war did that was good? We set up shop in the Middle East and brought them to us, getting them to fight and decimate as many as possible. While this was going on they were not worried about attacking the American Homeland. The middle east IS the stone ages as far as I am concerned.

I understand what you're saying, you've just gone from a YEAR of CONSTANTLY checking roof tops for snipers, turning around all the time thinking somebody is following you and watching your 6, mortars landing inside the Green Zone if you were ever there or your FOB etc? Then you return home and I don't care what anybody says you simply can't just turn off perpetually being at at high state of readiness all the time. Unfortunately at lot of men eat their guns because of PTSD.

How is your Veteran Affairs Department, have they helped you out in any way, maybe access to a psychologist/counsellor? Our VA Dept is top notch but then again we only had a couple of the 1000 troops at any one stage rather than you guys with tens of 1000s of military personnel in Afghanistan and Iraq over the 10 years...


Exactly. Everyone expects you to return home the same person. There is just no way for them to understand what we have went through. I remember right when I got home a few days later I thought, "I was engaged in firefights a week ago, and now I am standing in Wal Mart, what the hell do I do", almost exactly like it is shown at the end of this film.

The VA has group therapy and private counseling that helps a little. Their main thing is prescribing pills that do nothing but make me feel weird, like a zombie. Ours are overrun with soldiers so with the limited staff you dont get much attention.

What was your ROE, were you allowed to fire warning shots over their heads or was that too hostile and the possibility of hitting something or someone in the background?


Thats the thing, they were CONSTANTLY changing and were ALWAYS giving me the enemy the upper hand as they would figure them out quickly. Warning shots were supposed to be low enough to warn but not low enough to kill anyone. However, once they broke a certain barrier or made an aggressive act we were to light up the engine and them if the engine is not destroyed. The Insurgents would use children and women and shields. They would hide is mosques and snipe at us, knowing damn well we were never going to be given permission to return fire. Read up or the 82nd Airborne and see how we had the highest or 2nd highest casualty rate not only in Iraq but Afghanistan, which I was not at.


TThat must piss you off that movie makes up so many things in the movie that don't happen in real life. People must says to you that "so that's what it's like in Iraq for EOD or infantry"? When it makes their are so many erroneous scenes, dialogue and down right scenarios going against Standard Operating Procedures that it is embarrassing. The only one good thing you pointed out is where they filmed in Jordan looks like Iraq.
.

Eh, people have already made up their minds about us. When people ask me if thats what its really like I just tell them there is no way to properly explain it, and there is not. People like us know, but the civ have no idea and nothing will help them.

I could tell you had served in some sort of military by the way you were talking. Convoy security is the worst aside from foot patrols. A convoy is a juicy target, as they know a VIP is inside. Convoy security is where most casualties came from. They were the #1 IED target.










Haters gonna hate

reply

. But I finally realized how much it had to have sucked to be an Iraqi citizen.


It's like living in Mafia or Gang territory on steroids; honestly, it seems like most low level guerrilla wars seem to use many of the same tactics groups like Costa Nostra & other organized criminal gangs do. And it's not too far off the mark: before they became infamous as a criminal organization, the Mafia was a 'nationalistic secret society'. The "Law" in Southern Italy was ineffectual. In the 'new world', the 'sea' that the gangster 'fishes' swam in were the Sicilian/Neapolitan immigrants. They already have a built in distrust of 'Authority' because of how it was back in the old country. The Mob doesn't really have that many 'street level killers' but they have cultivated eyes & ears everywhere. And if you don't like the Mafia, who you gonna complain to? So you're sorta stuck. It seems like killing 'traitors' & 'rats' is an ongoing mission for these guys.






Why can't you wretched prey creatures understand that the Universe doesn't owe you anything!?

reply


Damn, that was an excellent analogy and pretty much nailed the point. Well said.


Haters gonna hate

reply

Thanks; I was reading a 'grass roots pacification' memoir from Vietnam one day & it just hit me one day.





Why can't you wretched prey creatures understand that the Universe doesn't owe you anything!?

reply

I guess since the US has invaded them, bombed their houses, killed and tortured them, they should automatically believe that American soldiers are trying to save their lives when they're shouting at them in a language they don't understand.

I know it can be hard, but you should try looking at things from other people's perspective sometimes. You would benefit from it greatly.

reply

Muslims seem to lack common sense.

reply