MovieChat Forums > Auf der anderen Seite (2007) Discussion > SPOILER director letting us know what wi...

SPOILER director letting us know what will happen


we have 3 black screens with white letters:

1.yeter's death
2.lotte's death
3.edge of heaven

why does he do that?

reply

I thought it prepared the audience for the inevitability of each "act" or segment. We invest a great deal in these characters, and we're guided past the loss of each of them to what the director has in mind. In life, we know we'll lose those we love (the certainty of death is our only guarantee in life), but doesn't it always come as a shock? Here, we're warned and told there is a greater purpose in life than simply holding on to what we want or expect. Nejat Aksu's journey towards forgiveness--in the terms of the film--is his fulfillment of God's covenant. Susanne's question, "Is your father still alive?" sets the stage for this, and it's reinforced by the director showing us Nejat Aksu's journey at the beginning of the film. We don't know what he's searching for--or why--at the beginning. By the end, it's our journey as well.

reply

It was a strange thing to do indeed. The first time, I had no idea whether Yeter was actually going to die, or something else would happen, such as a dramatic change in her life, or she wouldn't change or die at all and the title would mean something else altogether (I went to the movie with absolutely no previous info, just the way I like it best) - hell the movie could have been a comedy for all that I knew. But no, Yeter simply dies. So of course, when I saw the second title "Lotte's Death", I knew that Lotte was going to die as well. In fact, I loved the directness and frankness of the two titles. Thing is that the movie is not quite, or not just about Yeter and Lotte, but more about human bonding and human affection.

If you want to see it technically, the movie is about the regenerative abilities of the social network. In warmer words, it is about an individual's ability to survive in an ever changing social universe, where the persons, loves and hatreds he or she takes for granted keep shifting or disappearing. In even warmer words, it is about opening yourself to others, about going past the affective limits you have set for yourself, about unbuckling the various safety belts to reach beyond them. Yeter and Lotte were both braces and limits of their respective universes, keeping irreconcilable elements in balance and away from each other. With their disappearance, the two universes collapsed - and the last part of the movie sees how the remains of the two worlds reached beyond their balance and reconnected to one another. So the deaths of the two women were exactly that which the titles implied: two important chapters of the story, the first two of three. Thus the titles - and frankly, it hadn't mattered in the least that I knew Lotte was about to die (like I said, "Yeter's death" could still mean several other things to me) - though the two coffin + plane scenes were the very definition of irony, touch of destiny or good dark humour.

Additionally, that's why the ending makes every ounce of sense possible; seeing the father return and the son hugging him in tears would have been irrelevant (...not to mention flat and cheesy). What we see is the son opening his heart again to his father, and the final image is an awfully powerful illustration of this - the son waiting, on the shore of a (still) empty sea; maybe the awaited one will return, maybe not, but the waiting is there.

http://tinyurl.com/cuatro-balas
http://tinyurl.com/do-my-will

reply

In the first act of the movie, I sort of lost track that the hooker's name is Yeter so I didn't connect the caption with her death. I thought the caption was on a figurative death of something abstract. I guess it's good that I missed that so the accident came us a surprise to me.

So when the caption "Lotte's Death" came up, I knew what to expect and when Charlotte the character came up and I've gotten to know her and really liked her, I wasn't too happy anticipating that she would die. I'd rather not know.

So, I have to disagree with the need to do these captions. It's a good thing I didn't read too much about the movie beforehand so I still got an unspoiled fresh first-time viewing.





Billy Wilder Page, Play the Movie Smiley Game
www.screenwritingdialogue.com

reply

I honestly missed the first 2, don't know how thats possible lol. When I got the 3rd one I thought the movie was over.

I REALLY enjoyed the movie and found the deaths quite suprising and good plot twists. So maybe I rated a different movie then. I don't know why would director think tittle sceens would make the movie better...

9/10

reply

I didn't like that part at all. Keep at least some suspense.

reply