I would've given them to the Croatans
When the dishonorable cowards attacked the Croatans(Croatoan is an "alternate" form of Croatan) against the direct orders of Ananias, I would've-had I been in Ananias's shoes-bound them hand and foot, put them in the boats, and taken them back to the mainland. I would then have called the Croatans out and given them over to them to be done with as they pleased. I am certain I will get responses indicating how traitorous that would be, but I consider them traitors for their actions, and cowards of the worst sort for their sneak attack on the Croatans.
Sometimes evil is just applied stupidity-Ronar