Watched it for the 3rd Time...

And still not sure why people hate this film. Smith never once tipped his hand. He stepped out of his norm and made a really clever Suspense Film. It had elements of Horror, the Action scenes were played out well and John Goodman stole the show as usual. I'm not a fan of his other recent stuff but I just don't buy the hate here. All opinion of course but even after repeat viewings, I find myself digging into the twists and turns Smith came up with.

Makes me wonder... If this had another directors name attached to it, would it be held in higher regards?