MovieChat Forums > Battle for Haditha (2008) Discussion > Americans.. accept the truth

Americans.. accept the truth


Yes.. your nice kids who play football, eat Burger and date chicks in schools did in Iraq exactly what nazis did to innocent polish people in WWII. U know what U know from Fox news only and never see the complete picture.Some comment here that Iraqis shouldn't have put the bomb in first place. Great !.. But what sent U to Iraq ?.. Iraq never terrorized U or shot a bullet at an american. Before U invaded Iraq there was no existence of Al Qaeda there. Any one who konws anything about Arab world can never imagine Al Qaeda working with the secular Sadam. Now U turned Iraq to a terror factory.. genius !!. The same Vietnam scenario repeats itself like U learn nothing at all . Ten years from now some as***ole will convince U that Tanzania threats U and U will all go there to fight, listen to metal Rock and kill old men and children, talking all the time about Democracy and american values. I think I will be sick.

reply

[deleted]

I do not agree with us being in Iraq, nor do I even know the real reason why we are there (like you), but I do know one thing, we got rid of a genocide leader. So, be for you go on with your stereotypical, garbage point of views of America, get your facts straight. There is no way for me or you to know if Al Qaeda was in Iraq prior to the US occupation or if they had anything to do with 9/11... You comparing this to the Nazi invasion/occupation of Poland shows how small minded and uneducated you are. The Nazis killed roughly 100-200,000 Polish civilians during their stay in Poland. They deliberately killed and executed the majority of those civilians to "lower moral". You are comparing one of the worst wars/times in human history to something that was horribly depicted in a crappy movie. I know this is probably a way to get your jollies off, but I will not give you the satisfaction of lowering to your level. I merely want to point out your lack of intelligence. Also, I'm curious as to how you know the "whole picture" and we don't. Have you ever served in the armed forces in Iraq or Afghanistan? Case and point...

reply

[deleted]

Yeah do some research and realise that the majority of those iraqi civillians casualties were the result of their own people turning against them. Not the work of us soldiers. And no I'm not american. But I do know a lot of iraqis who managed to get out of iraq as well as people who have been there as contractors and soldiers. I don't hear that liberal crap from those who have actually been there. So I'm a tad sick of the number of people who blindly believe all the popular conspiracy theories (like michael moore's poor excuse for a documentary) without learning some facts for themselves.

reply

eaholum, your a brainless *beep* wait. It's people like you made other people want to crash planes into your country for revenge. Imperailistic bastards always blind themselves by thinking they are the "good guys"

Brainless piece of *beep*

reply

Folks, this *beep* is a troll of the worst sort. As if the excessive use of the letter "U" didn't reveal that already.

For anyone else caring to hear an American perspective, I offer you this: Half of us voted for Gore BEFORE we learned what idiot George was, and then we voted for Kerry AFTER we learned what idiot George turned out to be. And even as we watched the train wreck that was Iraq unfold, there wasn't a whole lot we could do about after he moved into the Oval Office.

The key word here is HALF, as in 60 million or so Americans. So please, stop with tired nonsense about America being evil and obsessed with world domination. All the tired cliches used by whatever-TF his name is apply to less than 1/5 of ALL Americans, a very small minority of the 300 million or so of us here wondering WTF happened to our country while GWB wasted that last 8 years playing golf and cutting brush.

I could go on and on, but I think about the fact that we Americans pulled a 180 once GWB was out of the picture: We elected our first black President; a man who seems to understand what's required to regain so much of the respect we lost from the rest of the world.

Yeah, America can make quite a mess when an idiot's running things, but we can also do quite a bit of good when we get the chance. When did the Nazi's ever participate in foreign aid missions? The only time the Europe gets involved is when they're shamed into it by American and/or British participation. We even tried helping the Russians with Chernobyl when they were considered our prime adversary during the Cold War!

Go and read the facts about every single disaster and see who provides the most when things go really bad. Take a peek at what Europe has provided in the way of donations to Haiti, versus what we have committed to. It's about 50:1, to say nothing of the members of our military, you know, the "pseudo-Nazis, hell-bent on killin'", that are there RIGHT NOW, passing out food, water and clothing.

Now that is something that should make you sick.

reply

For "toecutter-7"
Even you are one of those fighting against Bush junior or whatever president could come, you are an american that mean you are in war against every other people in the world and I will tell you what the reason is. Excuse my english, is not perfect (not beeing native speaker). First point america is not a country is an affair, a bussiness. Your country is based on extinction of other race (the native americans, the amerindians). You also as americans (continuing the british legacy) have created the corporatist style that is a plague to all human or living creature on earth and earth itself. I recommend you a movie "The end of Suburbia", is very well explained how it's keeped your style of life. You as americans are a plague to all other peoples because you consume more than 5 billion peoples, you waste the earth ressources and finally you think that is a good way. You consume more than you can afford normally, but you thing it's correct, you are in debt for eternity but you also draggs all other country to this, you start the eternal war but continue to think that is for democracy, the reason for starting this war is obviously wrong and fake (thinking of 911) but you continue to tell us that you know more than us and that you are right to do so.
Look, I have nothing against you personally but you have an imperialistic way to see things, first no empire until those day did nothing without an interest, second america is always in war with somebody (starting in WW2 acting as a world power), war that is producing money not for all the peoples but for a few gods (thinking that 1% or less of the population own 90% of the planet), third america is applying the way it fit better for its own interests, droping bombs if necessary, changing leaders, fighting for or against democracy if interests are demanding, etc. You could not agree with me because you are american, but we all see what is resulting after decisions took it by your leaders and would not be such a big problem if not applying by force all over the world.
I am from Romania, a country sold by americans and brits to the russians, a country bombarded by americans, a country where american soldiers are above laws, a country where all was sold and now owned by a corporation, where the minimum salary is about 150 euro, so don't tell me those stories about democracy and fight for freedom. I have not the time to write about all the problems because is boring but I hope that will come the day when you will fight for survival as we are doing right now, all the proud americans that you are! What I don't understand is why you take the side of leaders proves tehemselves to caching facts from their own citizens (see UFO stories, experiments made on peoples, drug tests, nuclear tests, etc). In your history is a lot of facts demonstrated with proves that your government made all those things but you are agree to them, you still support them even if not practically but in theory, and finally saying is about democracy. Is not for democracy, is for some elites the possibilities that they take everything from us and let us starving and praying for a dime or a slice of bread. How I already said, I hope that you as american citizen will feel on your own skin the benefits of your own medication (war, democracy, education, starvation, lack of choices, isolation, desperation, etc) but presented in a nice form of applying the new rules, new orders, etc, all under the statement that this way will protect you from harm inflicted by terrorists or some other creation of politicians. Read if you don't believe me 1984 or see the movie, see Brasil, The Manchurian Candidate, etc. And don't bother to reply with the same arguments as before in some earlier posts, I am old enough to not make statements because I saw in a movie. And by the way, the incident presented in this movie is real, read in Wikipedia or softpedia, is easy to search with google, and in the history were always incidents like this, don't forget that you are descendants of the creme of Europe (escapists, former prisoners, inmates, dezertors, adventurers, mobsters, criminals, etc) and your country is founded above the bodies of an exterminated population and with the gun in the hand. You still are a gun thinkers but you also have the disrespect to not even think about this.
Un liber cugetator care are curajul sa gindeasca si altfel decit majoritatea

reply

Costiputza said,"Your country is based on extinction of other race (the native americans, the amerindians"

Well technically so is yours as well. Romania is it? The whole of Europe was once the home of a now extinct primate known as the Neanderthal. Homo Sapiens (thats you) migrated into their habitats and whipped them out.

You filty Romanians! You should be ashamed of yourself for something that happened long before you were born and cant doing anything about!

reply

Interesting discussion, just my 2 cents to clarify some things:

1. "In addition to about three million Polish Jews (mostly killed in Operation Reinhard), up to 2.5 million non-Jewish Polish citizens perished during the course of the war. Most of them died in the Russian-occupied eastern part of Poland between 1939-1941. Over two million were ethnic Poles (the remaining 500,000 were mainly ethnic minority Ukrainians and Belarusians living in Poland). The majority of those killed by Nazi Germany were civilians (exceeding military deaths nearly 10:1)" from wikipedia's "Nazi crimes against ethnic Poles" article. That's slightly more than 100-200k right?

2. "Collectively the EC and EU member states comntributed 50.9% (US$4.4billion) of (world's) total official humanitarian expenditure in 2007." From Summary GHA Report 2009. I guess Haiti is an exception from the rule that Europe is the worlds largest humanitarian aid contributor.

reply

Its always funny to read americans defend the attack on Iraq. Yes, Saddam was an dictator, BUT it was YOUR dictator, installed by the USA. YOUR goverment helped him so long as he was useful for you. And nobody in those think thanks was thinking about the poor iraqis who suffered all the time. As soon as he wasn't any help anymore and turned against the USA he had to vanish. So maybe it is your job to get rid of an dictator you installed in the first place, but don't try to tell us its because of the poor poeple of Iraq, who had to suffer under a dictator.

If the US is so democratic why did it installed/helped dictators all over the world?

reply

whats funny is that those people could have told the americans about the bomb, and it would have been detonated, so i had to chuckle when they were throwing frag grenades at 'innocent' people.... LOL tell your damn story BEFORE you let americans get slaughtered, if you dont warn them, dont complain to the devil.

if this is how the story really went, then every one of those people except the americans deserved what was coming to them, and it was hand delivered, in a full metal jacket

reply

YOu dumb *beep*, they are SOLDIERS invading another country. They are the ONLY ONES who DESERVE horrible violent death! It's funny most of the *beep* who defend the troops are some of the most racist and xenophobic bastards who laughs whenever a black man or a Latino dies, but you suddenly care about them once they are in the army?!

reply

okay kditty, the people who were murdered were COLLEGE STUDENTS, fathers, mothers, grandparents, and CHILDREN.

Did it occur to you that maybe the civilians didn't KNOW about the IED? Or even if they did, did it occur to you that they were afraid of the Americans? And they would have had good reason to be afraid. What's scarier then a bunch of guys who are wearing full combat gear and carrying around automatic weapons? It's a very intimidating image.

How many Americans died in that road side bombing? One man, one American soldier died. Now I'm not trying to downplay the importance of the life of that soldier, but the value of his life pales in comparison to the lives of the 24 people who were snuffed out by a madman with grudge and a gun. Those 24 people had a future; those children and college students had a future. They could have made something of themselves, they had so many opportunities, but those opportunities mean nothing now that they are gone. They'll never grow up, they'll never go to school, they'll never have a family of their own, they are dead, and for what reason?

Kditty, I suggest you look beyond your little world, and put yourself in the shoes of others. People like you are giving Americans a bad name, and a bad reputation.

reply

ryusaki speaks the truth.

Read up on 'petro-dollar recycling' and 'Iraqi euro oil bourse' if you want to know why Saddam had to go. This was all to do with 'preserving the American way of life' as stated by the president which, incidentely, has subsequently crumbled due to the economic meltdown.

reply

[deleted]

alright, first off drop the anti-American sentiments and the stereotyping. We don't all play football, "eat burger," rock out to metal and take potshots at innocent people.

I agree with you, I am disgusted with what happened in Iraq. Those people didn't deserve to die, especially the women children, elders, and students. The attack left children as orphans, and 24 people dead. It was horrible, and its even worse that the perpetrators of the crime are getting away with what they did. The generals in charge are denying what happened and covering it up.

But you can't blame ALL Americans for what happened. Its wrong, its like saying ALL Germans are Nazis, ALL Muslims are terrorist, ALL men are rapists, and so on. Its just wrong.

You want someone to blame? Blame the American Government for their lack of action, for their greed, and for their inability to take responsibility for what their soldiers do. Most Americans are not informed about the war crimes commited in Iraq, hell I didn't hear about the Haditha and Wedding Massacre until today. Alot of Americans are against the Iraq War and the American occupation of Iraq. We all aren't blindly following and agreeing with everything thats been going on like you think.

I think all war criminals deserve death.

reply

Interesting thread... not for the topic, but to see the reactions. Using the killing of the Polish as an example is badly concieved. The Poles were 'exterminated' as a matter of national German policy, the actions of the state, not just a few, individiual soldiers. Reducing it down to just the bare actions, the atrocity itself, is way too limited and short-sighted. Devoid of context there are similarities, but it's a heavily contrived attempt to equate imo.

Given all that, there is a valid point raised by the OP, which cannot be denied. Propaganda in the US is not just rife, it's endemic (witness the hiding of US casualties and the blackout on dead Americans). mmmPeachy, I tip my hat to you, and I fully appreciate you are not alone in your opinions. That said, it is far too typical for Americans to defend and refuse such things, swallowing the propaganda whole.

I am English, but I have no apprehensions whatsoever in accepting and believing that British troops also committed atrocities, that innocent people were slaughtered and tortured, and that many soldiers simply despise the Iraqi people. It's horrible but it's reality. I see no reason to defend or deny that and readily admit it. And my view is hardly untypical in my country, which is the difference being pointed out I believe.

Contrast that with the typical American response to something like this and you can quickly see that the most typical reaction is to raise shields and go on the defensive, to put forth a multitude of mitigating factors, to explain it away and paint it as 'reasonable in war'. I see/hear this far too often and it stinks but it's unsurprising given the massive propaganda the US pours into portraying soldiers as 'heroes' - a phrase you hear ALL THE TIME from Americans. I suppose the collision of reality against fantasy is just too jarring for many Americans raised on the American propaganda of the hero soldier and the heavily distorted "romanticization" of war.


reply

good Point OP. Fools who nitpick on what he said about Poles...are doing just that nitpicking and tryign to defelct your attention from the real point OP made.


smoke and mirrors smoke and mirrors yanks...hahah fools.

reply


I am English, but I have no apprehensions whatsoever in accepting and believing that British troops also committed atrocities, that innocent people were slaughtered and tortured, and that many soldiers simply despise the Iraqi people.


What actual evidence do you have of this?

The only 'evidence' that I can think of was the monumentally irresponsible fabricated news paper article by Peers Morgan.

Still he's a big star in America now.


Only those with no valid argument pick holes in people's spelling and grammar.

reply

[deleted]

America TOOK DOWN YOUR DICTATOR and this is how you respond...... I guess you're right, America shouldn't meddle with other countries b/c their citizens OBVIOUSLY aren't ready for freedom.

reply

History Lesson...

HISTORY BELONGS TO THE VICTORS OF THE WAR... those who win the war write the story, and that his-story is made believed to be the righteous history by all. All of us writing here on the board, will show how we feel and behave about our past, present, and future... however, nothing will change eventually in real world, it hasn't for millennium after millennium, it's cyclical......

reply