meh


I went into this knowing that the film would be an obvious take on 'girl marrying one guy realises that she should be with her best friend instead' and frankly, I ignored that entire plot. I basically just watched this because it involved Scotland.

Also, the entire time there were scenes with Colin, I kept thinking, "Why would she /ever/ choose Tom over Colin? Is she mental?!" I may have been a tad biased, both in the fact that I love anything and anyone that is connected to Scotland, and I just cannot bring myself to root for any of Patrick Dempsey's characters. It was the same with Robert and Giselle in Enchanted. Giselle should have stayed with Edward, but I'm getting off topic!

If Hannah had been me, she would have married Colin, but I loved seeing Colin deck Tom. I may or may not have laughed.

I did laugh.

reply

Just saw the movie, it was so bad but i was feeling the same. Tom over Colin? No way! lol.

****
I'm not a psychopath, Anderson. I'm a high-functioning sociopath. Do your research.

reply

Really? You'd choose a guy you barely know, who treated you that way over a tiny piece of cake? They had WAY too many fundamental differences, if she had married him it would have probably ended very soon.

reply

Actually, I ended up having a mini discussion about that scene with my friend and we both agreed that Hannah was in the wrong to just reach over and expect Colin to share his food. It's only polite to ask first, even if she knew that he would share.

Also, why would Hannah marry Colin if she knew him so little? In my opinion, throughout the entire film, Hannah was an uncaring, rude woman that led Colin on and then publicly humiliated him. The way Colin was released from the relationship was horrible, yes, but he was saved from an horrid marriage and an even more horrid woman who, in the end, showed little to no remorse for her actions and how she treated him.

reply

She was marrying Colin because she thought it was her only chance for marriage, weren't they over 30 in the movie? I believe her character was supposed to be 32, she probably felt 1- she's getting up in age and 2- she needs to get married asap so she could have kids (assuming she wanted them, but since she was going to Marry Colin, I figure she'd be expected to have children).

In the wrong to sneak a bite of cake? My husband and I always take bites of each other's plates lol. I don't ask if I can have a french fry and he won't ask if he can grab a bite of my dessert lol. I would never freak out if my husband or soon to be were to grab a bite of cake.

reply

It really isn't important to think Hannah was being rude, or not, because that isn't the point that scene was trying to make. The important point of that moment is that Hannah and Colin notice that they don't know each other very well. They knew each other for one month before getting engaged, and then decide to get married in two weeks. That means they've only known each other a total of six weeks.

Also, why would Hannah marry Colin if she knew him so little?


Why would Colin marry Hannah if he knew her so little? For the exact same reason why Hannah chose to marry Colin: they were exhilarated over their new relationship and thought love and relationships were based on those kinds of feelings. They thought that was all it took for a marriage to be successful, but they were wrong. Hannah begins to realize that and the film portrays her concerns, but Colin doesn't seem at all concerned.

That's actually more disturbing because either he was too dense to notice, in denial, or running-over her feelings. None of those make for a great way to begin a marriage, most especially the third possibility.

I'm not taking either's side, as it's obvious they were both wrong to enter into an engagement without knowing the partner well. It was almost like Tom's father and his multiple ex wives. He jumps right into marriage when he should take everything slowly and find out if they're really suited for each other. It's interesting that Hannah actually asks Tom if his father doesn't realize he could just date these women rather than marrying all of them. Too bad she didn't take her own advice. But then if she had, there'd be no movie. And Colin was sort of just a plot device anyway, to make Tom realize he was in love with Hannah and wanted to spend his life with her.

but he was saved from an horrid marriage and an even more horrid woman who, in the end, showed little to no remorse for her actions and how she treated him.


Did you forget that this as a silly romcom, not a serious documentary, or docu-drama?

reply