The cops thought Hope Davis wore size 10 workboots?

No you didnt...and there was the whole strength issue. Its either plot holes or clues that the Lodger was real.

No, that's the single true fault in the movie.

...that and the fact that all the witnesses described someone who she doesn't fit the description of.

The movie ultimately lost me with its ending of "was she or was she the killer?"

It's one thing to be ambiguous, it's quite another when it seems the creators of the film themselves don't seem to know whodunnit.



"Phase One...in which Doris gets her oats!"