MovieChat Forums > Underworld: Rise of the Lycans (2009) Discussion > Who's hotter? Rhona or Kate?

Who's hotter? Rhona or Kate?

posted 15 years ago by offdwallnotdrack
82 replies | jump to latest

It's kinda hard to imagine anyone hotter than Kate Beckinsale, but there's something about Rhona that is so mysterious, she has those smokey eyes and such a subtle quality about her. She really does it for me. I'm actually gonna have to go with Rhona. You just don't see many girls with her kinda face, she looks a lil bit more unique, where as Kate almost looks too perfect, like a CG rendered model(nothing wrong with that though).

[–] phoenixcat 15 years ago

hasn't this discussion been talked to death. it was bad enough people thought rhona was replacing kate as selene, when she wasn't. kate played selene how she thought it was best, as rhona played sonja her way. yes, there are similar appearances w/the dark hair but, selene was supposed to look similar to sonja.

who's hotter? they both were in their respective settings. enough said.

[–] StJuno 15 years ago

Rhona. Part Bengali Indian, part English, part Irish. Balled up into one smoky-voiced, sultry, a**-kicker.

[–] StolenSilence 15 years ago

Rhona. Part Bengali Indian, part English, part Irish. Balled up into one smoky-voiced, sultry, a**-kicker.

This.

"I'm not normally a religious man, but if you're up there, save me, Superman!"

[–] hdma0415 15 years ago

Rhona

[email protected]

[–] elvis_rex2000 15 years ago

Definitly Rhona!i love her since Boston Legal, and her apperence in Nip/Tuck was memorable. i love Kate but Rhona is godess.

[–] cjoelmitchell 15 years ago

Close call, but Rhona wins it

[–] 15 years ago

[deleted]

[–] TigersWood 15 years ago

Rhona has bigger boobs. But Kate is prettier.
Rhona has a better ass. But Kate is a better actor.

I choose Rhona.

[–] 15 years ago

[deleted]

[–] highlord_leader_apocalypse 15 years ago

Kate

[–] StJuno 15 years ago

There's nothing 'hot' about Kate. She's pretty, the sort of girl you do couples tennis with and take home to meet your WASPy mother. She learns flower arrangements and scrapbooking. There was nothing remotely sensual about her sex scene in Evolution.

Rhona is incredibly sexy. The voice, the eyes, the body. The director or producer said that Kate was patrician and Rhona was almost primal. And that is exactly how I'd describe them. Kate is a corset, and Rhona is sex in the woods.

And an outdoors shag always wins.

[–] over_there 15 years ago

Kate is a boring standard beauty and that's why most people think she's hotter but there is really nothing special about her beauty, whereas Rhona has an exotic characteristic face plus she's athletic and beautiful.
Also I don't think Kate is a better actress, Rhona just hadn't the roles in which she could show that she's at least as talented as Kate. Kate is totally overrated, I really don't get what people find about her.

[–] patrik_ch7 15 years ago

kate all the way..not that rhona´s not hot, but kate is just hotter..and i love the way she manages to flash her fangs without looking like she´s doing it..don´t think i saw mitras teeth more than twice in the entire movie

[–] StJuno 15 years ago

Ick. Kate is missionary.

[–] jack-crow 15 years ago

In my opinion Rhona looks hot a s long as there is no other very beautiful woman around. Once that happens her rather rough features become apparent. So... if you put Kate Beckinsale next to her Rhona would definitely look a lot less hot.

[–] 15 years ago

[deleted]

[–] ndirish5567 15 years ago

Rhona, and it's not close.

[–] kupster 15 years ago

kate. hands down.

[–] Hotwyre6 15 years ago

Rhona.

Fear is the Mind Killer

[–] brianhclark-1 15 years ago

Rhona. Go watch Hollow Man. She is hotter than hot.

funny thing about Kate tho.... I saw a movie she did when she was early 20's and she was very unhot. She actually gets better looking as time moves along. Rare trait in a woman indeed.

[–] legnadibrom 15 years ago

rhona

http://www.last.fm/music/Disuse

[–] sinisterseven 15 years ago

Kate. Rhona has a manly facial structure.

[–] StJuno 15 years ago

She has a strong jaw; like other very hot women.

Kate is.... I don't know. She's just so damn WASPy. Ick.

[–] ironmaiden720 15 years ago

Kate is true beauty, as someone said she looks too perfect, but she really IS this way.. beauty lasts forever, hotness doesn't. Being hot is only for young bodies, there is no one that is old and hot. But beautiful? Always, and especially with Kate's case, as she ages very well and has gotten hotter and more beautiful with time.

I have spoken.

[–] StJuno 15 years ago

Actually, beauty fades. And Kate is lovely, not beautiful.

Rhona is sexy. Sexy is something you exude.

[–] leyenda61 15 years ago

uhh, did you see her in "Click". Day-umm!

[–] StJuno 15 years ago

Yes. And she's not worth a "Day-ummm!"

[–] leyenda61 15 years ago

Shee! Col' got ta be!

[–] Li-1 15 years ago

Kate, easily. That said, I generally think Rhona is hot, but she just didn't seem all that attractive in this film and paled in comparison to Kate.

[–] chinawhite252 14 years ago

how is Kate not beautiful? she is the perfect example of what beautiful is, you don't know what your talking about.

Cult Leader my mind's frightening, I drink blood from a human skull like a Viking

[–] ohmyhead 15 years ago

Kate = Goddess

Rhona = Gelfling with big fake cans.

[–] jqric 15 years ago

Definitely Kate, one of the most beautiful and gorgeous women in the world. Rhona has a good body, but a very average-looking face (compared to Kate).

[–] 15 years ago

[deleted]

[–] 15 years ago

[deleted]