4,9?! Are you kidding?


Of course, the film is not a masterpiece, but it worths more.

reply

Totally agree If it was from Bollywood...

reply

Totally Agree If it were from Bollywood...

reply

maybe it was a 9.4 but imdb messed up

it should at least be a 7?

reply

Definitely 9 for me. It's smart and well executed by all, maybe with the exception of the snitch. But I do know that guy like that has his appeals to some for their own reasons...

reply

Agree, it is better than the rating.

reply

4 months later its 5.1

reply

Film has only been out since Feb 2013. Also, look at the median 6.4 and average 7.0 which are much more reflective of this film... Imdb weighs certain critics votes higher for the final score. It's undebatable that people will give 1s and 2s much easier than they give 8s and 9s. Fact that this film has such a high number of 1s suggests to me that there's a strong negative reaction to the Jesus aspect of this film. Some take it as blasphemy. I didn't. I thought whole thing was refreshingly original. A very under-appreciated indie flick.

reply

thats true.. as of today stats for the top 1000 voters: Top 1000 voters 77(number of) 4.2(ave. rating)

it will shoot up to at least 7 in less than a year hopefully!

reply

why did the director want to make something smart, and funny, and touching, and light but full of depth, with some drama but more smiles and laughs than tears, while making the viewer think about life and death? why a remake of Amelie with a stronger and better story, more conflict, less love and friendship and a whole lot less charm? And how could he think -even for a minute it could work?

reply

It is what it is, and if it were rated higher, you would not be typing your masterpiece of opinion.

reply

I agree. I really liked the movie, too.

reply