This movie breaks my heart


I think it is so touching how Diana's imagined life is, more than anything, a tribute to Maureen. Diana chose to live her life exactly the way Maureen had planned on, even though Diana swore she would never live like that.

But what breaks my heart the most is that Adult Diana tries SO HARD to live her life and enjoy herself, but can't get past her depression. It's so sad to watch.

Adult Diana so desperately wants her daughter to love her... she so desperately wants to help out the failing student... she so desperately wants to come to terms with the school shooting... but she can't.

It just makes her death that much more sad... that no matter if you related to the Diana character or not, she was so full of life and had so much going for her and it was all taken away.

I seriously cannot watch this movie without bawling through the entire last 20 minutes or so.

reply

I completely agree with everything posted here.

This movie makes me so sad, since I can relate to both sides of Diana, it just makes this movie really sad for me, and I can't watch it, without bawling my eyes out for the last half hour or so.

i believe that we can be extraordinary together.
rather than ordinary apart.
-meredith

reply

Just in case you don't regularly check your PMs, I sent you one FYI.

reply

this is the first post i've read about this movie i totally agree with. i cried off and on during the entire movie and started getting a headache. i loved this movie but it was sooooooo sad. it forces you to think about things you don't want to imagine and who you really are and what you'd really do if in a similar situation.
the whole thing about her bio teacher really struck me as well.

reply

Beautiful thoughts, you are one of rare people who understood this movie, and therefore you can appreciate it, unlike most critics...

reply

Yay I'm so glad to hear from other people who loved the film as much as I did. I seriously do not understand why critics didn't like it more. This is a truly underrated film.

reply

howlingforever^

"...the whole thing about her bio teacher really struck me as well."


I know. A lesser director would not even have attempted to attribute some depth to this character, and it was so economically presented but still had some 'punch' to it. Well done.










"I can't stand a naked light bulb, any more than..a rude remark or a vulgar action" Blanche DuBois

reply

This is just my opinion. I just saw this movie and had to watch the ending twice and i also watched the alternate ending, which explained the story better. What I got from this movie is the bond of friendship. I feel that Diana looked at herself and looked at Maureen, a friend that she loved and made the unselfish act of sacrificing herself. She knew that there was good in Maureen. She know the mistakes she made in her life, she was kind of punishing herself, by the things she did as a young adult. The sleeping around, the crush on the professor, these things in my opinion are a cry for help. So, she gave up her life maybe because she thought she wasn't worth it and Maureen, who was good could have a chance at happiness. The flash forwards are what could have been if she hadn't but she would have never been happy even if she had lived.

And I do my little dance

reply

Amazing movie, this is so unfair that it has such a low rating here, but anyway - who cares. I'm glad I've seen it

reply

This movie was amazing. I was so shocked to see the end. I would have never guessed. Definitely worth watching!

reply

Really enjoyed the movie. (maybe because I'm in my 20's?) it made me reflect on life in general and different tragedies. the ending of the movie killed me. watching the bathroom door slowly go shut knowing what was going to happen to them? I never saw the twist at the end coming. I also love the song "Ordinary day" by James Horner that I Bought it on i-Tunes.

~I love the rhythmn it is my methoood!~

reply

This movie is totally heartbreaking.
I watched it with my best friend who is like Maureen but less religious and Me definitely being more spontaneous like Diana, we totally related.
When i realized this movie was about a school shooting it totally hit home and i struggled with finishing it. Columbine is my backyard and my high school and seeing the terror that happened there become so visually real on my t.v. was heart breaking enough. Plus Diana's struggle with depression was almost too much to watch altogether.
This film is beautifully filmed though.
Inspiring. It was like watching poetry come to life.
It deserves more credit.
great acting too. those girls were genuine friends.

reply

This movie was wonderful, I too cried off and on. So many different aspects made it great: the cinematography, the screenplay, the book it was based on, the acting, the score... I could go on and on. Anyone who says that film isn't an art form, well, watch this movie. It is the perfect example of art, if you ask me.

T~O
Does that make me an accessory to cat rape?

reply

Yeah but!! She couldn't have done any of these things that make you sad because she was shot dead as a teen!!!!

reply

[deleted]

I also cried the second time I watched it, when I understood it better, when Diana dove into the pool after and was holding onto the side with one hand, and gently touching her abdomen with the other. If you listen carefully, you can hear what sounds like fetal heart sounds. It's like she realizes at that moment that there is life inside her. Then when she tells Maureen that she doesn't think that her heart is her strongest muscle...and completely proves that wrong when she gives her life for Maureen's.
Very complex movie, several great layers, and well worth watching.

"Level head? I think mine's level, and yours is the one things would roll off of."

reply