Disappointed


I'm a witchblade fan of both the comic book and the TNT TV series that starred Yancy Butler.

My boyfriend had gotten volume 1 and 2 for me for my birthday this year as a suprise. Now, I do not, nor have I ever really LIKED anime, so I winced, but figured I'd give it a try.

I have only watched two episodes, but so far I'm disappointed in the extreme. Nothing seems to be true to the original story, other than the capabilities of the "Witchblade" itself.

Does this get any better? or does she always remain a bratty whiny bitch that can't seem to function?

Any help with this would be appreciated...

Wenchy

reply

I like it alright. You just have to keep in mind that this is a completely new Witchblade story having nothing to do with comic or television installments other than the Witchblade itself. It goes to a new woman, no other connection.

*"You think just 'cause a guy reads comics he can't start some sh!t ?!?"*

reply

I totally agree with Wenchy. I guess that its because I am also not a fan of Anime. You can NEVER count on decent storytelling with anything done with Anime and they continue the tradition with how they screwed up Witchblade. I understand that it's supposed to be a whole new era with a new wielder, but the story is f#@$ing rediculous! At least they could have had a real child voice the new girl's daughter.

reply

While I can understand why you may be disappointed with the anime - not to your taste - you can't knock the plot. The anime's plot is top notch if you give it time.
Masane Amaha is your typical, protective mother and will do anything for her daughter. The new ability she discovers within herself brings both a shadow over that motherly nature and her own personality. In later episodes this is explored alot more, with constant conflict between her two identities and other problems.

Overall, the anime was done superbly to my liking. The ending is a real tear jerker.

By the way, Sulalee, I strongly disagree with your comment on how animes 'have bad story-telling.' There are alot of animes out there with mind-blowing plots to rival, and even better, a Spielberg production. If you want superb story-telling then watch Ghost in the Shell, need a touch of poignancy then watch Devilman Lady.
I cannot find a fault with how the story progresses in both.

reply

I feel the complete opposite of the TC.

I never really cared at all for Witchblade until I saw the anime. I watched the TV show and I really couldn't get into it at all. However, I watched the anime I really enjoyed it. I then tried to read the comic, but I just couldn't get into it that much either.

With that said, the anime Witchblade is its own seperate beast entirely. I really liked the dramatic and realistic approach to the story and characters, and I thought it had a lot more sex appeal than the comic. Masane's character definetly felt a lot more down to earth compared to Sara. The anime is definetly my favorite version. Even though the comic has a much bigger and wider universe, the anime made a big impact on me within its short 24 episodes. But I guess it depends on which one you see first.

reply

I'm actually amazed you attribute bad storytelling as a characteristic of anime. What anime have you seen to make you arrive at that conclusion? I've seen quite a few anime series that exhibited fantastic storytelling, and quite a few movies and tv shows that did a terrible job in that regard.

I'm sure when its all said and done, no matter the medium, it all falls to the skills and capabilities of the directors and creative teams behind the shows.

reply

I was all set to go on a long tirade defending Witchblade as it's one of my favorite animes to date, but if you didn't like what you saw so far, nothing I say about how good, emotionally charged, or heartbreaking it gets will matter to you.

I will say this; if you don't see it through to the end, you're cheating yourself.

-
I will close my ears and my heart and I will be a stone

reply