Why The Need To Remake?


FT.com:
http://www.ft.com/cms/s/0/bfa9253e-97fc-11de-8d3d-00144feabdc0.html

Variety:
http://www.variety.com/article/VR1118008061.html?categoryid=14&cs=1

Hollywood Reporter:
http://www.hollywoodreporter.com/hr/content_display/news/e3i82908c6716f89cd1b1fa7fe34a0f173a

Blog:
http://blog.zap2it.com/frominsidethebox/2009/09/who-should-star-in-a-remake-of-prime-suspect.html

I understand they want better shows to secure ratings for networks, but making a remake of this series on American television is going to be extremely hard. It will not compare to Helen Mirren's portrayal and creation of Jane Tennison. Who would be cast in this role?

reply

I completely agree. Read my response in the thread for Prime Suspect 1. I absolutely hate the idea of an American remake. I feel the need for a rant coming on over this. Oh wait, I already did that over there.

reply

As an American and great fan of the series, I agree with you 100 percent. Helen Mirren's performance as Jane Tennison will never be equaled.

However, many British series have been successfully remade here. And we've made a few great ones all on our own. Case in point: "The Wire"


The Wire...the best series in the history of television

reply

It's more of Hollywood's incessant need to find pre-sold properties, rather than take a chance on an original idea. You don't find many risk takers in Hollywood anymore, especially in this economy.

I hope that this fizzles out as the previous attempt at a US version did in the 90's. At best, it will come off like the US Life on mars, a pale immitation with a laughable conclusion, rather than its own entity, with the same character names and premise.

reply

Hollywood originality is dead.


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h5GZIDnMzZQ Why does Canada need a queen?

reply

Wait, was there an attempt prior to the Maria Bello outing?

reply

After Prime Suspect 1 was a hit on PBS, the rights were optioned by Hollywood. A script was in development. There was talk of doing it as a motion picture, though Mirren as discounted because she hadn't been the lead in a major film (just supporting roles). I believe Linda LaPlante was involved. Nothing came of it, thankfully, any more than the American Absolutely Fabulous ever got off the ground (though it came a lot closer, with actual casting, before the plug was pulled).

Even at the time, I felt no one but Mirren could carry it off. The later attempt pretty much proved it.

At the time, there was some feeling that Mirren's Oscar nomination ofr the Madness of King George was more a recognition of Prime Suspect, than her role in the film, given that she has so few scenes. However, Judi Dench won a few years later for less than 5 minutes of screen time.

Fortunately, Ah keep mah feathers numbered for just such an emergency!

reply

I know my response is six years late but I just saw this series on Netflix.

I'm 66 years old so I am fully aware of how career women have been treated since I first went to work as a professional programmer / graphic designer (yes, TWO careers). i was 12 and it was 1960.

The character, Tennison, that Helen Mirren played is not worthy of respect except for the fact that she 'always gets the perp', eventually. The writers made her a rather predictable character slash slut. Maybe in the first 1-4 series, but after that she was a
GROWNUP WOMAN. Typically, in MY experience, women over 45 who were sluts in their younger years are NO LONGER playing that game. They've been there done that and not so likely to pick MARRIED men to *beep* Why not? BECAUSE WE ARE ADULTS NOW and have far more empathy than we may have had in our 20s-30s.
By the time Tennison is portrayed in Series 6, when she's 54 years old, it's bullcrap that she'd have slept with a younger coworker, someone who REPORTS to HER.

Writers, you do a MAJOR DISSERVICE FOR WOMEN IN THE WORK WORLD, PARTICULARLY THOSE WHO WEAR BLUE (COPS i MEAN, SINCE THAT may be an american term). Women are acknowledged by even the American Medical Association (a notorious male chauvinist organization) that WE ARE SMARTER THAN MEN. By 'women' I mean GROWNUP women, over 45 or thereabouts.

I'm ashamed how writers portray women and men in character studies, in particular. But then again most tv writers are immature, emotionally unbalanced people with not a lot of brain power, so I guess their 2-dimensional portrayals of characters is to be expected. SAD. REALLY.


Life is a journey not a destination. Fear nothing.

reply