MovieChat Forums > Noise (2007) Discussion > A guess at the 'ringing' significance (S...

A guess at the 'ringing' significance (Spoilers)?


I am watching this right now and can look at any part of the movie and discuss.

"I believe in coincidences, I just don't trust them." Source debatable.

reply

I thought at first the tinnitus started at the same time as the murders, but in the beginning of the movie he states to the nurse that it had been going on for 18 months.

I have had some thoughts on rewatching the film.
We listen to music like the girl Lavinia to tune the world out on purpose. Graham's tinnitus is like this all the time only very unpleasant.

Also, it must be extremely safe in Australia. A young attractive and apparently helpless woman can get on a train/subway in an abandoned station late at night (presumeably) and pay no nevermind to who might be on the train and what terrors might be there.

I say this in light of the fact that the movie has a very real feel to it. People seem ordinary and real.

"I believe in coincidences, I just don't trust them." Source debatable.

reply

> it must be extremely safe in Australia.

I agree, um, though never having been to Australia.

Folks might wanna consider that local news punch up / exaggerate fears, worldwide, just to highten their ratings?


__________________________
Dr Horrible: "With my Freeze Ray I will stop the world."

reply

It's the snakes and spiders in Australia that make it dangerous. And that's without even going in the ocean. Probably not a ton of giant toe-munching spiders on subways, however.

reply

I get the feeling "noise" symbolizes many things in this film. One possible significance is fear. One of the big themes of this film is fear and how it affects us. The girl in the train was practically consumed by it when she realized the killer had her name. And when the cops refused to give her any info, the paranoia nearly drove her mad. Finding out the actual "dead meat" threat was almost a relief compared to not knowing.

Similarly, Graham has this ear condition which could be a routine ear disturbance or it could be indicative of a brain tumor. We never know for sure, but it's obvious that the fear of a tumor is constantly on his mind. When he's apprehending the guys beating up that kid, the noise raises to a deafening level. Again, that's fear taking hold of him.

The one scene I didn't really grasp was when he comes home and turns on all the radios, tvs, faucets, etc. It was almost like he was using noise to calm himself somehow. I wonder what noise symbolized at that moment...

reply

Finally, what does the tinnitus have to do with the movie?
Revelation!
Remember the girlfriend saying how sounds cancel out. Right after the killer shoots the driver passing by you hear the constant beeeep of the car horn. The horn cancels out the sound in his ear so that Graham can hear the killer's footsteps and shoot his feet under the car. If Graham had not had tinnitus he may have not heard the footsteps due to the car horn?!?!

His destiny was guided. No tinnitus, no caravan duty, no dead killer. Why the whole talk about heaven and hell? Why the imagery at the end of the movie?

Thank you
:pwned

"I believe in coincidences, I just don't trust them." Source debatable.

reply

Finally, what does the tinnitus have to do with the movie?
Revelation!
Remember the girlfriend saying how sounds cancel out. Right after the killer shoots the driver passing by you hear the constant beeeep of the car horn. The horn cancels out the sound in his ear so that Graham can hear the killer's footsteps and shoot his feet under the car. If Graham had not had tinnitus he may have not heard the footsteps due to the car horn?!?!

His destiny was guided. No tinnitus, no caravan duty, no dead killer. Why the whole talk about heaven and hell? Why the imagery at the end of the movie?

Thank you
:pwned

Though this is very neat and Signs-like, I don't really buy it. I don't hear any buzzing during the shootout at the end, nor does it seem like Graham has difficulty hearing anything. Whenever Graham hears buzzing, there's buzzing on the soundtrack. So why is there no buzzing at the end if he's experiencing tinnitus?


IMO:

Graham doesn't experience tinnitus at all after his girlfriend hums it away. I think the tinnitus was caused by general unease and depression, which is cured by the realization that he loves his girlfriend (which is understood by both, though he never says it).

After this, he's essentially at peace with himself. He accepts his death, and it's implied that he gets some measure of salvation (even if it's just a few seconds of happiness before he brain dies).

Either way, great movie.

reply

After watching this again some years later I still think this still is very fitting scenario. Now the new Aussie film Strangerland.....that one's not so tidy, every bit as riveting. Noise could have used some world recognized actors, but definitely more realistic Aussie life style. Thank you.

I believe in coincidences, I just don't trust them. - Source debatable.

reply

[deleted]