MovieChat Forums > Thank God You're Here (2006) Discussion > TGYH - The Judging was a shocker on 6/5/...

TGYH - The Judging was a shocker on 6/5/09


I realise that the judging on TGYH is not really serious at all and often the winner trophy is not awarded to the best performer on the night (otherwise there are a few of the top guests that would probably win each time they appear).

However, Tom's decision from Wednesday's show was not even remotely credible in my opinion. I thought that Josie Long was clearly the worst on the night. In her individual scene, she was very bad with the exception of the part where she pretended to vomit when she learned that her boyfriend was her brother. For the other parts of the scene, I could see the glaring difference between the question-answer style that I had seen in some you-tube clips of the UK series and the style of the better guests from the Australian series.

In the group scene, she was clearly the worst of the four and the decision to award her the trophy was amazing. I felt embarrassed for the other guests and even for the Tom (and as I said before, I know that the best on the night doesn't necessarily win for various reasons).

But this choice was just sad. I'm disappointed to see that Josie is scheduled to appear in another episode later this season.

reply

thats just like anthony field in season 2 tho.
he didnt deserve to win. he was just repetitive and the only funny thing he actually said referred the wiggles. and in the all in part he just let hamish do all the talking and he just went along with whatever he said. the judging is so stupid sometimes

reply

[deleted]