MovieChat Forums > A fost sau n-a fost? (2006) Discussion > location essential to movie meaning

location essential to movie meaning


There seems to be confusion on the whole meaning of the movie, stemming from confusion on location within Romania, probably due to the English-language title.

The location of the movie is Vaslui, a very small provincial town on the eastern border of Romania (quite far from Bucharest, which is far south; the distance between the 2 is of hundreds of kilometers). Vaslui is the director's home town.

The question the writer/director poses was whether there was a revolution in '89 *in Vaslui*. There is no doubt there was one in Bucharest (or Timisoara). For background, the Romanian revolution was quite bloody, far from a velvet one, featuring tens of thousands in the streets, barricades, snipers, armored vehicles and many deaths within Bucharest and Timisoara especially. It ended with a dictator fleeing from the top of his building by helicopter and a firing squad for him at the end.

The movie questions none of that (thus all comments about the movie arguing for a 'velvet revolution' are somewhat misplaced). His question is whether what we understand as a 'revolution' happens down to smaller, distant towns of a country (or layers of society) and how soon people that are *not* in the first 'line of fire' adapt to, acknowledge or actually participate in major changes. One can speculate a lot, but this main meaning of the movie was confirmed several times by the author himself in interviews and such. In addition to that, perhaps it's a commentary on post-revolution Romania as well IMO.

reply