MovieChat Forums > Hacking Democracy (2006) Discussion > Why Not Use Paper Ballots??

Why Not Use Paper Ballots??


Down here in Auatralia not only is it compulsory to vote but all votes are cast and counted on paper ballots. To us the mere thought of voting machines is ludicrious simply because technology like that can be tampered with. Australia has no spectre hanging over it like the US with regards to our elections.

The US claimes to have the greatest democracy in the world yet clearly has a flawed voting system that is open to manipulation. I understand that our population is much smaller than yours but using paper ballots and enduring a small delay in the final result would be far better than the corrupt system you currently find yourselves with.

reply

Agreed.

Thar Diebold POS almost seems like it is designed to be tampered with, but even a good system would still be vulnerable. Who/what could guarantee the system or results are not tampered with, whatever the system is.
Computers are not for everything, and I say this as a computer nerd.

Like here in Finland voting places and in counting of the voting, there are representatives from different parties and organisations. They count the votes together twice (or more if needed), and can wath over each other that nobody is bluffing.
What could be better than this? Sure, it takes manpower, but those machines don't come cheap either (was it $100M in California?)

Still some politicians here too try to push voting machines here too, mostly those who don't know anything about technology.

reply

Ask the Democrats - they screamed bloody murder about these following Florida 2000, and insisted that the poor and minorities stop being discriminated against and be provided with electronic voting machines. Be careful what you wish for, Dems...

reply

there can be fraud in paper ballot counting too so what's the point of going back in the medieval age and use them

reply

Yeah, when you are done filling out your paper ballot, you feed it into a
digital counting-machine. So it really doesn't make any difference now does it?


'Dim X as Integer = 0'

reply

In Canada, voting is done on paper ballots, in polling stations that serve between 700 and 1000 people at most. The ballots are counted by hand and are monitored by electoral officers. Nothing is 'fed into a digital counting machine,' as one poster mentioned above. This system might seem old-fashioned to some, but Canadians, as far as I know, have no serious complaints about it.

reply