MovieChat Forums > New York, I Love You (2009) Discussion > Nasty movie!

Nasty movie!

posted 13 years ago by JarJarRocks
1 reply | jump to latest

I just don't want anybody to go in and think this is a warm, light hearted romantic comedy (like we did.) This was one of the most depressing movies I have seen. And it made me never want to go to New York. I guess they the best words to describe it is a real life drama, with a few hints of romance (but very, very little).

It looked and felt like a home made movie, with bad camera quality and almost no story. And the few stories that were there seem unexplainable, even more than an average David Lynch movie.

If you like drama, and watching other people's boring depressing lives, then I guess this is for you. But if you're expecting a nice romantic movie, you're gonna be extremely disappointed.

[–] KelseyLovesFilm 13 years ago

It seems like you watched it and only saw the surface. Each episode in the film had a deep story and it all had to do with love. Love isn't always light-hearted. Love is complex and beautiful, much like this movie. Tell me, which episodes did you have trouble following? And who on earth told you this would be a light hearted rom-com?