MovieChat Forums > Joshua (2007) Discussion > Wasn't the MOM ANNOYING!?!?!

Wasn't the MOM ANNOYING!?!?!


OMG, her stupid "half crazy" facial expressions, etc. A woman who, by comparison to today's WORKING mothers, has everything she could ever NEED handed to her on a silver platter. She was a HORRIBLE & unfit mother (evident in the video tape when she couldn't even handle Joshua as a baby). And what is with calling her mom-in-law all kinds of disrespectful names & such?!? Me & my mother-inlaw can have our spats, but the level she took it was totally uncalled for.

For the record, the actress Vera Farmiga is MUCH, MUCH better in the similar, yet superior, Orphan movie.

--
Nightmare Man:6.5/10
Brave One:7/10
Infestation:5/10
Rabid Dogs:8/10
Unhinged:5/10

reply

Ommggg yesss!!
i was just like what a crazy ass bitch!

but i did laugh my ass off when she was like, "He was an old dog. Every dog has its day and Boomer[[i forget the dogs name so i made one up]] had a *beep* *beep* day"

oh mannn...that was soo funny.

You just shat your pants in the middle of a meeting,you sat at a desk and just shat yourself--WKUK

reply

Yeah, she was awful... and she knew it, that's why she let everyone see her enjoyables.

reply

She must be a great actress, because I couldn't stand her.

reply

OMG, yes she was HORRIBLE. I mean, I know she had post-natal depression and Joshua was possibly messing with her meds, but as the video from when Joshua was a baby showed, she was HORRIBLE back then, too. Also, she only had 2 kids to look after and a husband with a nice job so she could stay at home. What about mothers who have to juggle work and raising kids? What about mothers with more than just 2 kids to look after. The mother was a foul-mouthed, spoilt, upper-middle-class witch who I honestly think didn't want children at all - she doesn't seem to show any affection to Joshua other than when she plays hide and seek with him, and even Lily seems to be more a 'possession' that she doesn't want to 'share' even with her husband.

reply

She was a nut case if the baby was driving her that batty get a darn nanny and get your lazy ass out and work. I'm so sick of women claiming depression when all it really is is being stuck in their own heads. I notice ppl that get out and help others don't become depressed.

reply

Depression is a real thing, not something women "claim" to get out of working. You should educate yourself before making these comments.

reply

[deleted]

Uhhh...

reply

It was made clear that Abby had seen a psychiatrist for 17 years and obviously suffered from post-partum depression with Joshua. In addition, Ned mentions mental health issues running in the family. Joshua simply exploited Abby's frailties.

I thought Farmiga was excellent.


"Well, I was raised here. I turned out okay."

reply

Yeah, that little Hellion would have drove anyone nuts.

I wanna kill him more than anything!

reply

She had every right to speak to her mother in law like that, MiL had no right interfering in Joshua's religious upbringing, she's not Joshua's parent

reply

Not to mention the mother in law's comment about how she should be praying instead of treating her depression!

reply

The whole damn family was annoying.

reply

I agree. It seems she just didn't know how to raise children, at least at an infant level. The baby cries just a little and she practically blows a gasket at everyone in the house. Plenty of mothers have children that cry every night, it doesn't make them half-insane. She had severe emotional issues. I wasn't surprised at all that the husband appeared to be considering an affair halfway through.

reply

I don't know if the people commenting about this are parents (especially mothers), but if you aren't, you cannot possibly understand the stress caused by a continuously cranky infant, which would multiply times 100 if you have PPD. Dealing the the hormones and emotions that you experience post birth, plus the general sleeplessness of a new mom, is hard enough without having a constantly cranky baby around.

My mom had a very stressful pregnancy with my older sister and she believe to this day that my sister (as a baby) was negatively impacted by the environment caused by the pregnancy. She was a baby who screamed EVERY HOUR that she was awake. My mom didn't even have PPD and told me that she never understood how people could shake their babies and hurt them until she had my sister. She used to go outside and cry because she couldn't stand the constant screaming. And my mom was not only mentally healthy, she was a nurse who loved children. When my sister got older, she calmed down but my mom never forgot what an awful baby she was. It's why she waited 10 years before having me.

There were definitely times that my own twins drove me to tears with their crying and they were very good babies generally who rarely cried. But when you are a new mom and the screaming doesn't stop, it takes a psychological toll.

All that said, I hated both the parents in this movie.


That hexagon-face bitch, she's so passive-aggressive.
-SpencerFan

reply

I agree with you. My son was a sweet, big happy baby, and I thought "How easy is motherhood??" He never cried, he played happily with his toys and met all his milestones ahead of time. Just a wonderful baby boy. Then--I had my daughter.

We waited several years to make sure we were financially ready, and I wanted another baby so very much. She was so beautiful I thought I'd lose my mind over her! After about 2 weeks, she developed colic. And, she kept it for nearly a year. She also had a problem with her middle ears, so she always had vertigo or earaches. She cried non-stop for the first 2 months of the colic, and couldn't ride in the car without severe stress. She couldn't be rocked because of her ears. Her only relief was walking her, on my shoulder, for hours until she fell asleep.

Her daddy was out of town 1-2 weeks at a time for business, and I had no help with her. It was the most stressful time in our little family--making time for my son, trying to get rest between the marathon crying sessions, and maintaining our house while feeling like a zombie--I nearly lost my mind. We worked out a system that wasn't the best parenting plan ever, like allowing the baby to fall asleep and lie with me propped up in the bed. Slowly it became manageable, and she became old enough for some medication to ease her gastric distress. We managed, but it gave me a whole lot of insight into post-partum depression and the mothers who are very young who might not have the emotional maturity to handle babies with difficult infancies.


~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
"Let's eat Granny!! Let's eat, Granny!!"
Punctuation matters.

reply

Yeah but she probably should not have had another baby if she was so traumatized with the first one.

I would say my memory is not what it used to be. But I don't remember what my memory used to be.

reply