MovieChat Forums > Mushishi (2005) Discussion > Plot: or a lack thereof.

Plot: or a lack thereof.


Let me preface this by saying that I adore this anime. It's one of the most interesting, refreshing titles I've seen in recent memory. However, I feel like there's something holding it back from being truely excellent. As it stands now it's a pleasent watch but I can't quite bring myself to give it a perfect score - it's stuck at a 9/10.

I think the issue is the plot (or lack thereof).

Obviously the show is purely episodic, but I was watching it as it was aired (without any knowledge of the manga source material) and felt that there were a few opportunities for the show to really grasp onto a theme or plot element and pursue it in later episodes.


Some of the best opportunities might have been right in the first episode (The Green Seat) where the drinking ceremony was inexplicably interupted by a raven - since I was unaware of what the show was due to become, so I thought it might become a driving plot point. Or, much later in the series, episode 20 (The Sea of Brushes) when Ginko comes upon a mushi that must be trapped within scrolls or else an evil (of sorts) will be released upon the world. Since the series went on a hiatus at this point (we waited for several months before being able to see episodes 21-26) I thought that when it returned it would revisit that story for at least another episode or two. But alas, it was not meant to be. The series continued on as it always had.

I know it's redundant to hypothesize on what the anime could have been, since the series is complete. And perhaps I'm looking at it from to mainsteam a perspective - obviously the series didn't need a plot to be successful. Its lack of plot even went to shape the theme of the show that while we may be temporary, some things are eternal.

I just wish there were a bit more to it.

reply

I agree that this show is hard to watch because of the lack of any continuing narrative or character development. Every episode is a small story on the subject of Mushi and their effects on human lives, nothing more, nothing less. You either like that, or you don't.

I do think a ongoing plot would make it easier to follow the show. After 12 episodes I decided to take a break and watch something else, purely because it became boring to me. But I had to watch it further later on.

This is like a very good book: hard to find your way to the end, but worth the effort once finished. One must be willing to accept that it isn't ''cheap'' entertainment like a Naruto or a Bleach.

reply

Each episode is self contained, there is no need for a ongoing plot. Sure it would be nice to learn a little more about Ginko, but each episode stands on it's own as a nice short story that it doesn't hurt the show in my eyes.

reply

What I truly missed was that I wanted to know so much more about Ginko's past. We get to see a few things but those glimpses are just small parts of his whole life and hardly explains his character, his thoughts and ideals and why he is like he is. That was the only thing I ever found rather disappointing since as the show progresses, more tension around his character is built up since he is the main character but still remains to be such a mystery to the viewers and readers. I don't mind having it episodic, I think it was one of the reasons the series feels to relaxing although it intensified my fear of the dark for some reason. I have a very strong paranoia over things I cannot see, so when I go to bed I keep imagining evil mushi creeping in everywhere... or something like that. You get the deal. That is the most ironical thing this show caused me or any other show for the matter since this show is obviously not trying to scare you still it scares me more than most horror shows I've seen. They just contain a lot of gore nowadays, not even that becomes surprising anymore.

reply

Have you not watched the episode on Ginko's childhood, and how he lost his eye? It's about 2/3 of the way into the series.

reply

watch episode 12, it explain why Ginko becomes who he is in the series.

reply

Definitely agree 100% with jess_davis

reply

I think its because it was based on the manga and they basically took the "best" chapters of the mangas and made it into 26 stand alone episodes.

I believe the manga, overall, is very sparse about Ginko other than what was shown in the anime.

They say, on ANN, that there were 7 volumes released in japan and they're being translated and distributed in English by Del Rey:


http://www.animenewsnetwork.com/encyclopedia/manga.php?id=4779&page=28

http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/search-handle-url?%5Fencoding=UTF8&search-type=ss&index=books&field-author=Yuki%20Urushibara



NOTE: The last japanese release was made after the anime series it seems (2006) so I guess there's a continuation to Ginko story after the anime. :)





"Why are you worrying about your beard... when you're about to lose your head?"

reply

Not every anime has to be dragonall z or bleach or naruto with 5 million episodes and a completly ridiculous plot and story. Each episode is a story in itself and they are very good stories.

Whos to say the "plot" wasnt about Ginko and his travels?

reply

I concur with that notion!

reply

The problem with a "plot" or standard, point A to point B style of thing is that a lot of animes/movies/etc go with it and forget to do anything else. Had this anime done what you are asking, it would have diminished the quality of inventiveness and originality it had.

You are indeed looking at it from too mainstream a point of view. Everyone is used to the standard story format, people forget stand alone stories exist. Sometimes the journey isn't where you are going, it's where you been and all....

That's why this anime was such a hit. There is such a huge universe in Mushishi. Have you had Ginko try to defeat one big evil Mushi the whole series, it would have had to focus less on all the stand alone stories. The Mushi and how he handles them and people, would have been overlooked and the series would have been at best better than average.

Stand By For Action!

reply

It's written like a anthology show with only Ginko as the main character, it's not supposed to have a plot really.

reply

Yes, quite so; it's a series, not a serial. As are the Sherlock Holmes stories, The Simpsons and most sitcoms - a diverse bunch of references, if you like. You are not meant to watch them all in a single sitting. Enjoy each story as it stands.

reply

I think if it had been written with an overarching plot centered on Ginko and some of his relationships, it may have diminished the primary role that the mushi and the subject of each episode play. I, too, would like to know what happens between the Ginko and the girl who is writing out her disease - does she get to go an adventure with Ginko?

reply

They need to make new episodes based on the completion of the manga, through volumes 10. They stopped it around volume 7. There are many more stories and some focus on recurring characters from the past.

reply

There is no overarching plot, however I see a overall theme (ignoring the whole Mushi stuff).

Usually the character (other than Ginko) has undergone some sort of trauma (physical / mental) and towards the end of the episode, the character somehow overcomes that, at least partly.

I am currently going through a rough patch and could not help but notice how sad this series was. But then I am seeing the brighter side of these episodes which is kind of reassuring in a way.

reply

Uh, I just want to know how he got his clothes.

JK. I read that manga was originally supposed to be set in modern times, and the authors decided to keep his original attire design; I think this just adds more to the mystery surrounding his character, despite us getting a peek into his origins. It would've been interesting to see how the authors could've worked his clothes into the plot, since he does stand out so much from everyone else already.

But personally, I like the anime the way it is. It's refreshing to, as a viewer, be able to contemplate over this entire piece on my own & leave more up to my own imagination.

reply

It is definitely the most original manga / anime story out there. I like that it does not try to copy any style or story from some "let's fight the aliens" or "high school sex romp" anime. ;)

reply

Exactly. For a show that was intended to reflect the universal human condition, overarching plot is simply redundant.

I find this show a good relaxation after the plot bombardment from other series, any coerced plot would simply spoil the fun here.
_________________________
Superbus Via Inscientiae.

reply