MovieChat Forums > HGTV Design Star (2006) Discussion > No wonder the winners of this show are a...

No wonder the winners of this show are always lackluster

posted 11 years ago by MrBuzz13
1 reply | jump to latest

The judges eliminate the good contestants, Anne had the best design skills AND on-camera skills of any of the contestants this season, she was the total package to the tenth.

The person I least want to win is Jeribai, because excluding his weirdly fake suave black guy impersonation in the tv challenge this week, in place of who he actually is, a boring stiff, he has no on-camera skills.

As for Tiffany, Anne outperformed her in virtually every episode, so why she's there I have no idea, she's a poor man's Anne.

And Brooks is too eccentric and manic to receive my confidence as a host.

The judges couldn't even come up with logical reasons why they booted Anne, they said her designs were too consistently good or something to that effect, whatever judges.

[–] magickemerald 11 years ago

I guess they were factoring in creativity, and her designs are too consistent. That being said, yeah, she was a great designer with some good hosting skills. Probably the most similar to any of their current HGTV show hosts.

I still think Tiffany would be enjoyable; not sure about Jeribai, it's a toss-up as to whether or not I'd watch him. Brooks is a little too "out there" to appeal to every type of viewer, so I'm not sure a show with him as host would succeed.

They do always seem to get rid of the best designer! Maybe the show needs better judges???

---
Tell your god to ready for blood.