MovieChat Forums > HGTV Design Star (2006) Discussion > Agree with judges this week (spoilery)

Agree with judges this week (spoilery)


I'm so glad about this week's elimination. Though Anne's designs could grace any high end store window or stage set, (which is of course impressive) they were fairly one note. And her personality grated on me from the very beginning; hard, bossy and shoulder chippy. I like the others...cutie Jeribai has great all around skills, but they have a bunch of those on the network - Carter! Can!
Tiffany is sweet, I like her a lot and her designs are solid. I might watch her, but not every week.
hgtv needs a little injection of something different and fun and not forced and if Brooks can somehow reign the manic (which I don't mind, but I suppose I see why the network might not want it) he could be fascinating and utterly brilliant. I'd indeed watch him every week because his amazingly cool unusual designs make me want to see what he'll do next.

reply

Quit quoting Genevieve's idiotic opines, she's a fountain of misinformation, the evidence doesn't support what she said, hence does not exist.

Anne's designs weren't just good, but stylistically diverse, I'm a man and I liked her stuff, hence she wasn't just doing pretty designs, but ones that functionally fit any environment.

You also swallowed her schitck about Jeribai having all-around skills, when the exact opposite is true, his only true skill is carpentry, his on-camera skills are nonexistent, put him in front of a camera and you have a boring show.

And what was up with him and his Barry White act in this week's challenge, he can't sustain that because it's not him, he has as much soul as a geeky accountant, we know this from the first 4 episodes.

How many times did Anne win the top designer award? Atleast 3 times, while no other designer won more than once. Hence the decision to eliminate Anne this week was completely contradictory, and Anne had the best on-camera skills of any of the remaining designers to boot.

If you rewatch this week's episode, the only negative comments that surfaced about Anne were brought up by Genevieve, she single-handedly railroaded her, I'm not sure of her motive(s), but she's the reason Anne is gone, the other judges could not think of a single negative thing about Anne, they pretty much laid down for Genevieve on this one.

reply

I'm not sure why they place so much emphasis on stage presence. Year after year you see the winner have a show that quickly ends up on the cutting room floor. Take the best designer and use them on some of their established shows.

reply

Well mech aren't you awesome for accusing a complete stranger on the inter webs for not having opinions of their own. Anne blew chunks and it was a pleasure to again see her booted in tonight's recap....sigh of pleasure...

Cheerio!




"To me you are the teacher in a Charlie Brown cartoon"

reply