As much as I am a huge proponent of the idea that one should not make inflammatory statements without having evidence to back it up, I have to side with Ams87 here.
There is a key difference between what Ams87 said and what Mstanford01 said.
The OP (Mstanford01) more or less accused James Woods of acting like a jerk and saying people could not stand him, without any evidence or even a hint of where evidence might exist.
On the other hand, Ams97 blamed CBS' bad judgement for getting the show cancelled.
What Mstanford01 said was, whether correct or incorrect, an issue of facts. You can have an opinion about what constitutes acting like a jerk, in fact, that's pretty much almost always going to be subjective, however, the statement that "people could [sic] stand him anymore," is not subjective. Regardless of whether or not anyone can prove it, it is still either a true or false statement.
With what Ams87 said, there are two ways to look at it. The first is that while Ams87's statement might also be on the surface one of fact, in reality any reasonable person who really takes the timeto think about it would realize it's not. He or she never really meant to imply that they could provide concrete proof like a memo or something that would show that CBS purposefully moved Shark's tiemslot in order to have it fail; it was obviously more of an expression of frustration directed at CBS.
However, if you want to try to argue that we should take his or her statement literally, then quite frankly, we're covered there too. Because when it comes down to it, CBS cancelled the show. That is an inarguable fact. No one else could have gotten the show cancelled - it's not as if ABC or NBC could have decided "hey we don't like the competition, we are cancelling the show." Hell, even if the writers decided they wanted to sabotage the show and trash talked every single sponsor the show had, the bottom line is that all those sponsors could do would be to call up CBS, read them the riot act and threaten to pull all of their money, but in the end it's still CBS that has to cancel the show.
reply
share