MovieChat Forums > Numb (2008) Discussion > This film is a great resource for suffer...

This film is a great resource for sufferers


Like many of the people who have posted on this board, I am a sufferer of DPD. Although I have been receiving treatment for DPD for a while, this film brought to my attention a few interesting facts about DPD that I was not previously aware of.

For example, the book that Sara was reading in the scene after Hudson tells her about his condition is real, and is the first, and to date, only English book about DPD. It is called Feeling Unreal, and is available on Amazon. The study on blood Cortisol levels that Dr. Blaine finds for Hudson is a real study, and represents huge progress in the understanding of DPD's biochemical roots in the hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal axis.

The research group in Mount Sinai is also real, and is run by the world's leading researcher of DPD - Dr. Daphne Simeon. While I am glad that the research group was given exposure in the movie, its depiction here is utterly disgraceful. The doctor who is presumably based on Dr. Simeon is portrayed as a hopeless academic whose attempts at understanding DPD have been futile. In reality, many of the patients who have undergone experimental treatment at her clinic have experienced temporary or even full remission. If you are accepted by her research group, don't be put off by this movie - GO!

Indeed, every piece of information gathered from this film should be taken with a grain of salt. Just off the top of my head, Divalproex sodium (prescribed to Hudson by the psychopharmacologist) is not an antipsychotic, anxiolytic, or in fact at all useful in the treatment of DPD; combining MAOIs (Monoamine Oxidase Inhibitors) with Duloxetine (a Selective Serotonin Reuptake Inhibitor) as alluded to in Hudson's drug "cocktail" results in serotonin syndrome, and probably death.

So, while Numb is a great film, and can be a great resource, if I may say a word to the wise: use with caution.

reply

actually there are more books.

http://www.amazon.com/s/ref=nb_ss_gw?url=search-alias%3Daps&field-keywords=depersonalization&x=0&y=0

this has a list of available books on amazon.

also, depersonalization belongs to the category of dissociative disorders. in a nutshell: when you depersonalize you dissociate. but depersonalization is a specific form of dissociation. my point being: there are lots of books on dissociation. and so, while there isn't that much on depersonalization, reading up on dissociative disorders can also be useful/ helpful.


i agree that the movie shouldn't be taken in all seriousness for the sufferers. i think it should be taken in all seirousness by professionals - because it is just horrendous how the therapists were presented or the phrama guy. i think the point with the drugs and the 'cocktail' they were trying to carry was that *beep* loads of doctors prescribe meds almost at a whim: "oh this doesn't work, fine then try this" hoping that one time it will work and ignoring to inform the patient about the side effect. and side effect are HUGE !! for example one of the side effects of fluoxetine can be increased suicidal thinking!!!!!!!!! so great doctor, thanks, that really is a side effect not to worry about... also what they didn't show, but maybe it's a common knowlege, is how much money the pharma guy gets from prescribing those meds. every time hudson went and bought certain drug from the prescription by the pharma guy the pharma guy gets paid up. it is horrendous.

how is it possible that neither therapist had touched upon hudson childhood is beyond my understanding, and how come his truamatic experience of being kicked out of the house by his mother has never been explored in the therapy??!!! and just when i thought this cognitive behavioral therapist will be helpfull she goes all nuts on him.

but in reality not all therapists are like that (i hope the majority isn't), many people out there have gotten better from therapy.

reply

Magezia, you just don't get it, either. This is a romantic love story wrapped around DP. If is was just about DP NO ONE WOULD GO SEE IT!!! Take a step back here. FYI, most therapists are terrible. Most prescribe drugs exactly as in the film. But the picture is NOT about therapy. It's about this guy who meets a girl.

reply

[deleted]

Re: Teacher. This is NOT a documentary. It's a film. Despite the subject matter being partially about DP, it is an entertainment first. Why? Because no one would see it otherwise. You think cop films are based in reality? Or any film for that matter. You want this to be exact because you suffer from the disorder. If it delved any deeper into DP, it would have been a dark drama. The film doesn't slam Dr. Simeon. It uses that as a useful reference so there "is" some organic basis to the story.

reply

"Many patients of the Mt. Sinai clinic have experienced temporary or full remission"? I find that very difficult to believe. I tend to think the way the doctor is portrayed as being clueless is more accurate. That's certainly been my experience. I doubt there is any effective treatment for DP at all. I never found one and I've looked hard.

reply

Out of curiousity what type of treatments do they try to at this Mt Sinai Clinic? I'd like to have hope but I have a feeling lorenzb is probably more accurate

reply