How can anyone rate this 1/10, let alone 12% !?!?!?! This is awesome! If you watch a documentary I guess you like documentaries, and this is one of the best!
share[deleted]
It's down to 10.5% now but 10,000 people have given it a 1/10 hoping it would drop, amazingly it's still on 9.5 ahead of Breaking Bad & GOT.
"Hail to the king baby"- Ash
I think it's pathetic to downvote a show just because it's ahead of "your" show. GoT is my favorite show ever, yet I wouldn't downvote anything ahead of it. I gave Band of Brothers a 10/10, because I think it deserves it. I haven't rated Planet Earth, because I haven't watched it (but I might some day, and if it's as good as people say, I'll gladly give it a 10). And I gave Breaking Bad a 7/10 (sorry, but to me it's nowhere near as perfect as people think it is) which is still a good rating.
And yes, I gave GoT a 10/10. It's a wobbly 10 right now that could drop to a 9 if next season has the same quality as the previous one. When I rate a show, I rate ALL seasons. BoB and PE don't have this problem, both being miniseries with one season only. But other shows that are still going and have lost or are losing their spark are a bit overrated in my book. Sure, The Simpsons were hilarious at first, but eventually the fun dried out and the show kept going anyway. When I rate it, I rate the entirety of it and that's not a good rating anymore.
Same with The Walking Dead. As much as I loved the first season, after a couple of seasons of filler, poor character development, repetition and buttload of other problems, I can't give it the high rating anymore that I gave it at first.
Bottom line: People need to get their priorities straight. Very few shows could maintain the same high level of quality throughout and therefore very few shows deserve a 10. A miniseries is more likely to maintain quality.
You should check out peaky blinders, all of it, then rate that. Also, Turn Washington Spies. Amazing and underrated shows. Also Black sails season 3 could be one of the most exciting seasons of any tv show, the first two were amazing too. Def check out Vikings too. Nicely written reply btw.
sharePlanet Earth II is now number one TV Show.
share