Angus,
I don't doubt that the show gets good ratings, as my kids (8 and 5) both like it a lot. It is pretty safe, inoffensive stuff and is one of the few shows for the pre-teen market that doesn't revolve entirely around 'dating' and jealousy. I guess I regard the show as a modern-day equivalent of something like Rentaghost - a fairly wholesome kids' sitcom that is entertaining and isn't going to do anyone any harm.
Performance-wise, I think you guys do a decent job with some pretty ropey scripts. I agree with some other posters who suggest that the girls are a touch too smiley, and although character development is hardly going to be the primary aim of a kids' show, I feel that more could be done to differentiate between them - but let's face it, this is not Brecht.
I do feel it is obvious that the show has been made to look and feel American, which is more of a lament than a criticism. I keep expecting the girls to announce that they are making plans for their senior prom, or to say that they have just been to the mall. Doubtless you will correct me and say that the property used for the exterior shots is in fact in Bridlington or somewhere, but no-one could possibly say that it is representative of a typical British house, and I find that very sad. Is it not possible to sell a show like this overseas unless the house looks like it's in Malibu or Long Island?
My only real problem with the show is the casting of Jordan Metcalfe as Adil. I don't doubt that he is a decent actor, and a job is a job - but what the heck is going on here? When I was growing up, Michael Bates was hamming it up as an Indian in It Ain't Half Hot Mum and nobody seemed to bat an eyelid - but surely we've moved on a bit since then! If you're going to have a character who is a genie with a Middle-Eastern name and pantomime-style Middle-Eastern costume, why on earth get a caucasian actor to play the part and affect a daft 'foreign' accent? I guess that this might have been done to avoid being accused of racial stereotyping, but surely if that was the problem, it would have made more sense to turn the whole thing on its head and bring the genie character completely up to date. As it is, this casting really doesn't work at all.
I'm glad that you enjoy making the show and I'd be interested in your comments on the points I've made.
Cheers
Tim
Early to rise, and early to bed, makes a man healthy (though socially dead)
reply
share