MovieChat Forums > Yi He Yuan (2007) Discussion > One of the best and most important films...

One of the best and most important films of this decade


This is the greatest film from the People's Republic of
China I've ever seen. Not to mention the most important
and courageous; the Tiananmen Square massacre literally
split the film (and the lives of its characters) in half.
This is the number one taboo topic in China, of course,
and no one else dares to touch it. For their trouble,
the director and screenwriter got banned from filmmaking
for 5 years. (I thought they could have gotten a lot worse.)
The DVD has interviews with the filmmakers, who remained
upbeat, even poetic about their plights. But the film
is not preachy at all; it is more of a mournful remembrance
of what happened in the late 80s when the filmmakers came
of age. I wonder how much of it is autobiographical. In
a time when Chinese movies are dominated by Zhang Yimou's
fascist budget-busters on the one end and Jia Zhangke's
mind-numbing formalist exercise on the other, Lou Ye's
unsung triumph is such a breath of fresh air. One day
it will be recognized as the important masterpiece that
it is.

reply

I agree that almost nothing else out of PRC is as sublime and honest as this film.
It compares with Chungking Express.

reply

Gee, not all of Zhang Yimou's films have been "fascist budget-busters", although admittedly he's been less impressive since the turn of the century.

And honestly, I felt that a little bit of Jia Zhangke-like subtlety in the post-Tiananmen Square sequences and a more consistently restrained score might have made this the masterpiece it almost was.
_____
I suppose on a clear day you can see the class struggle from here.

reply

I can't agree with you more.I am Chinese and I love the movie so much.From the beginning to the end I have been weeping.The movie might be about personal feelings of a special lost generation,but I find it so touching and deeply moving.

China has always been a depressing country.We Chines are so blessed that there are brave directors like Lou Ye.His works are always my favorite.

reply