Disappointed-Spoilers


I was expecting to see a biopic along the lines of Ray with Jamie Foxx. This movie was mostly about Davis' adventure trying to get his tape back with a Rolling Stone writer. A very small amount was spent on his youth. Then at the end they had no mention of when he died, or how, or anything. So I went home and looked it up on Wikipedia. I thought Cheadle was funny and a good actor, but still wasn't what I expected.

reply

Opposite opinion here: I'm really glad I didn't see a biopic along the lines of Ray / Walk the Line / The Doors / Coalminer's Daughter / etc, etc. Some of these movies are good, some are bad, but this template of musician biopics is so very stale and has already been satirized nearly a decade ago with Walk Hard: The Dewey Cox Story.

After seeing what I thought was an awful trailer full of clichés, I went in expecting the worst, but was happily surprised that Miles Ahead tried to break out of that mold. There's a few musician biopics which try to break the mold -- some fail, but I like that they're trying.

In the end you say this film compelled you to read up on Davis, and that it "wasn't what [you] expected" -- those aren't bad things!

reply

[deleted]

...it tries to mimic the inspirational style of the music so wholly...

I saw that happening, too. I agree that it was a big mistake. It might be attractive as an artistic challenge, but it's an intrinsically impossible task.

It comes down to the director imposing his visualization of what's in the music on the audience, and that's where things can go wrong like they did, here.

That it's all done in the service of telling (let's face it) a pretty stupid story further compounds the problem.

Despite solid performances from the cast, the more I think about the other elements in the film, I like it less and less.

*Danny's not here, Mrs. Torrance*

reply

Quite liked the film and the performance and direction of Cheadle - nice use of different film exposures to go back in time, nice cutting from a reverie to a memory or back to the present. Pacing well done, with a nod to jazz improv. The fictional story and characters touch on the issues facing a musician and record labels demand for new "product" and a kind of holy grail ala the film Diva. A straight bio kind of movie about Davis would nearly be impossible. The wild shifts in Davis' life is touched on here effectively. The 50's (the cop-set up was real), 60's, 70's are nicely recalled.

reply