Led Zeppelin


Why was the zeppelin bombing Trinity College? Is that a strategic military site? Also it was pretty much a sitting duck up there.

reply

There was military training at Cambridge, a hospital for wounded, tent camps, etc. Early on, the military wasn't in the position to damage/destroy the zeppelins, but later figured out and developed means of heavily damaging the machines with explosive shells, which could set the hydrogen on fire.

reply

Is it not against the Geneva Convention or something like that to bomb a hospital?

reply

The Geneva convention wasn't enacted until after the Second World War

reply

[deleted]

You're thinking of the 4th Geneva Convention. There were three that took place before World War II, the first being in 1864, second in 1906, and the third in 1929. Each one revised and added to the previous one, so today, the term "Geneva Convention" would mean the fourth one in 1949, but at the time the movie takes place in, it would refer to the second convention.

reply

Damn, when I saw your subject line, I was hoping to find that LZ music was in this movie. But I guess that would be extremely inappropriate! :) Probably going to see it tonight.

reply

If anything they should play Kashmire

reply

The song is called "Kashmir". It's somewhat fitting as a tribute to an Indian mathematician.

reply

lol just posted the same thing.

reply

It was made up by the producers. I do not think that there was any Zeppelin raid against Cambridge or against any hospital. The aiming was awfully poor though, and there was one bomb which fell half a mile from the intended target and hit a hospital. The raids where against military targets, but as the aiming was so poor, the bombs hit more or less randomly. In all of the raids together, about 560 people died (civilians and military personnel). The myth created around these Zeppelin raids helped to justify Britain's bombing aimed at German civilians in WWII, killing about 600.000 civilians.

reply

Slightly off topic but something I never understood. I thought bombing was for military targets, so why in WWII did Germans send bombs over to London and bomb people's houses, and similarly we bombed the crud out of Leipzig and Dresden and they had to move J. S. Bach's grave (I think)?

reply

Well, why do humans kill humans? The usual reasons, I suppose... greed, racism, misinformation due to propaganda. In the case of air strikes, an additional factor is that even when the official target is a military installation, civilians still die due to the lack of precision. Maybe some pilots did it even on purpose. This leads to revenge bombings and thus to an escalation, in particular if both sides do not really have a problem with killing civilians. The specific case you mention is described as having started this way on wikipedia:

"This was a result of a rapid escalation starting on 24 August 1940, when night bombers aiming for RAF airfields drifted off course and accidentally destroyed several London homes, killing civilians, combined with the UK Prime Minister Winston Churchill's retaliatory bombing of Berlin on the following night. From 7 September 1940, one year into the war, London was systematically bombed by the Luftwaffe for 57 consecutive nights."

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Blitz

The BBC adds

"When on the night of 24 August 1940 the German air force - the Luftwaffe - accidentally and against Hitler's orders - dropped some bombs over London, the British prime minister requested a retaliatory raid on Berlin. Hitler responded by going ahead with the Blitz, and the following months and years saw tit-for-tat raids on each country's cities. [...] An investigation revealed that just one in five aircraft was succeeding in dropping its bombs within five miles of its target. Under such circumstances, the bombing offensive could only be effective if it was directed at targets as big as cities. Consequently, in February 1942, Bomber Command was instructed to shift the focus onto the 'morale of the enemy civil population'."

http://www.bbc.co.uk/history/worldwars/wwtwo/area_bombing_01.shtml

reply

Actually, I thought they randomly launched bombs from Germany and aimed them at London, called "buzz bombs"

reply

Maybe you are confused about the timeline? The V1 was used close to the end of the war, in 1944. The war was far beyond any "why" at this point.

reply

Not confused. I did kind of say a little off topic. I did mean WWII and I know this movie was WWI. Nonetheless, I wondered ;-)

reply

Maybe I am missing something here. About what exactly did you wonder? I really thought that my longer reply answered your question extensively.

reply

yeah. Thanks

reply

Various leaders thought countries could be bombed into submission. There was the idea of destroying means of production and sapping morale. Also there was a concept of 'revenge bombing' - I suppose there is a question as to whether or not revenge delivers any strategic benefit, maybe sometimes, other times - no.

reply

Due to the OP I expected an Epic Led Zep Soundtrack!

reply