MovieChat Forums > The Man Who Knew Infinity (2016) Discussion > Raman credits his findings to goddess na...

Raman credits his findings to goddess namagiri


In India, people use deities in very powerful ways. Any number of Devi worshippers are there, when they sit in front of the Devi, they have a tremendous insight into various aspects of life, but once they step out, they will be innocent of what they uttered just a little while ago

Ramanujan was a brilliant mathematician from India. He had very little formal education, he was mostly self-taught, but he went to Cambridge to work with various mathematicians there. When I say mathematics, you need to understand it is not a school subject. You can convert the whole creation into numbers; that is mathematics. It took years for great mathematicians in the world to understand his work. He did many theorems and said they were given to him by ‘Namagiri’ – his deity or gopddess. He had initially refused to travel outside India, but later agreed when his mother received permission from Namagiri for him to go to England in a dream.

While on his deathbed in 1920, Ramanujan wrote a letter to his mentor, English mathematician GH Hardy outlining several new mathematical functions never before heard of. In his own words – “While asleep, I had an unusual experience. There was a red screen formed by flowing blood, as it were. I was observing it. Suddenly a hand began to write on the screen. I became all attention. That hand wrote a number of elliptic integrals. They stuck to my mind. As soon as I woke up, I commited them to writing.” In the last 90 years, nobody understood what his theorem was, but they knew it was something tremendous. Only in 2010 did they find out that this theorem describes various behaviors of black holes. Ninety years ago, no one was talking about black holes, the term did not even exist, but Ramanujan made a mathematical impression for it sitting on his deathbed and he said ‘my Devi namgiri’ gave it to me. When Ramanujan says, ‘Devi gave it to me’, for him Devi is the doorway.

reply

being a hindu brahmin , im aware of this , in india there are many gods and goddesses created by the yogis for specific purpose

reply

Fascinating. On the INTJ forums, it's often discussed that Indian religions may see intuition as being of spiritual origin. Intuition is also commonly described by intuitive thinkers as the "Cacophony of Competing Voices", and as the 'Parliament of Ideas'. It is seen differently by intuitive feelers (they tend to characterize their intuition as 'street smarts', 'just knowing people' and the like).

Incidentally Tesla (another clear intuitive) also stated he received his ideas from metaphysical sources. This is quite common belief among intuitive thinkers, and not just among Indians.

reply

Nikola Tesla used ancient Sanskrit terminology in his descriptions of natural phenomena. As early as 1891 Tesla described the universe as a kinetic system filled with energy which could be harnessed at any location. His concepts during the following years were greatly influenced by the teachings of hindu yogi Swami Vivekananda. Swami Vivekananda was the first of a succession of eastern yogi's who brought Vedic philosophy and religion to the west. After meeting the Swami and after continued study of the Eastern view of the mechanisms driving the material world, Tesla began using the Sanskrit words Akasha, Prana, and the concept of a luminiferous ether to describe the source, existence and construction of matter. This paper will trace the development of Tesla's understanding of Vedic Science, his correspondence with Lord Kelvin concerning these matters, and the relation between Tesla and Walter Russell and other turn of the century scientists concerning advanced understanding of physics. Finally, after being obscured for many years, the author will give a description of what he believes is the the pre-requisite for the free energy systems envisioned by Tesla.

telsa said “If you want to find the secrets of the universe, think in terms of energy, frequency and vibration."

The day science begins to study non-physical phenomena, it will make more progress in one decade than in all the previous centuries of its existence."

“My brain is only a receiver, in the Universe there is a core from which we obtain knowledge, strength and inspiration. I have not penetrated into the secrets of this core, but I know that it exists."

http://www.teslasociety.com/tesla_and_swami.htm

reply

The day science begins to study non-physical phenomena, it will make more progress in one decade than in all the previous centuries of its existence."


The problem with this is that it isn't really doable, we don't have any reliable mechanism for studying non-physical phenomena, as intuition is a very poor tool that can take different people into different contradicting directions.

reply

I think as we study the human brain more and how it functions, we will get the insight needed to build the tools to measure this phenomena

reply

This was an excellent post by the way, though I fear I was a little late to recognize it.

reply

All great scientists have great intuitive mind , all great inventions occurred because of intuitive mind not from intelligent mind

http://www.newsgram.com/how-scientists-like-niels-bohr-schrodinger-nikola-tesla-and-albert-einstein-found-the-true-meaning-of-physics-in-vedas/

reply

you mean this https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mock_modular_form ?

Yeah the claim checks out, I guess having a Field medalist adviser does pay off.

The more I look into the literature surrounding this movie the more I am impressed by this guy, I mean before he was just a name occasionally popped up in lecture notes.

The forms given to him by his goddess :))) were investigated in this http://arxiv.org/abs/0807.4834 - a phD thesis ! (this is to say it pays off to look into legends of mathematics). The paper shows the connection of these forms to Harmonic Maass form https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Harmonic_Maass_form - this is the first time these weird functions have a proper framework behind them.

However the connection to black holes was only found in 2012 I believe, in http://arxiv.org/abs/1208.4074, this paper basically says certain mock modular forms (after some technical maneuvers) shows up as generating functions of BPS states
(https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bogomol%27nyi%E2%80%93Prasad%E2%80%93Sommerfield_state) in certain supersymmetric string theories, which are relevant to the study of black holes from the perspective of quantum gravity. Which, connects his goddess to modern mathematical physics (I suppose anything can happen when you talk to your god in your dream), you can also google the AdS/CFT correspondence, and especially umbral moonshine.

The skeptic side of me tells me that the mysticism comes from the fact that he is deeply religious, and it happens all the time that a mathematician's work is connected to some mind blowing physics phenomenon a few hundred years later, and some attribute their work to their favorite deity.
But upon closer inspection it might not be so easy to put Ramanujan into this category. Grothendieck for example, influences Algebraic Geometry, Algebraic geometry influences to cryptography, robotics, and genetics, so the media might claim Grothendieck's work influences cryptography, robotics, and genetics, but from what I know Grothendieck's work by itself has no direct applications in these field ! it is just a useful advanced tool, replaceable. Ramanujan's forms on the other hand, have a strangely direct conceptual tie to some theoretical model that was created by people in a different field, and in a different era. Of course when we have another Newton to unify everything such connection might become as obvious as differential and integral calculus, but right now it isn't.



reply

Show me a math genius from India who never studied math and says he got it from the gods and I'll show you a con artist. India is full of them, tricksters.

reply

my dear , its the reality , ramanujan never went to any college or university , he owe his finding to the goddess namigiri , in ancient india people used deities for their own work for prosperity , power etc, india was one of the greatest civilization in the world . maths , yoga and many other great things came from india , however present india is poor because of the islamic and british invasion . mantras, tantra have another dimension of science in them

reply

Not going to university does not mean that he did not practice math for years though.

// gergely-szabo.com

reply

Sorry to burst your bubble man, but what these great minds perceive as 'intuitions' and 'divinations' received directly from 'the center of the universe' is basically just manifestations of their own intellect. It's a byproduct of evolution. When you look at a seemingly unsolvable problem, and then the solution dawns on you just like that(as it always does, when the brain finally connects the patterns without you even knowing it), it feels like a miracle. Especially when you can't see how you arrived at it.

But in the end the case of 'divine intuition' always boils down to a grand delusion. Ramanujan may have felt that the gods were speaking to him due to this common fallacy coupled with his rigorous religious intonation and belief in mythical concepts, but it was in fact his own brain on overdrive, arriving at the results. Same goes for Tesla, minus the religion.

As for your views on the 'divine knowledge' of India, they are simply baseless. Everything from Aryabhatta's and Susrutha's work to the Yoga were created by brilliant humans. The Tantras are scientific because they were invented by men using 'scientific' methods. You are simply crediting mythical gods for the hard work and intellect of humans. Reminds me of an old joke where a doctor performs a successful surgery and the patient thanks the Gods.

reply

Srinivasa Ramanujan was not a con artist.

reply