MovieChat Forums > Life on Mars (2008) Discussion > Any historical inaccuracies?

Any historical inaccuracies?


One thing i like to do when watching period pieces is to see if i can find any historical innacuracies. But i didnt seem to find anything in 1973 that seemed out of place..anyone else?

*********************
Conservatives hate what people do -- Liberals hate who people are.

reply

A Barack Obama speech plays on TV. Clearly inaccurate.

reply

None. I didn't catch any. I look for that stuff too. Out of date packaging or obvious bar codes, car models especially in the distant backrounds. products that weren't invented yet, phrases that weren't in use yet. None. They did an awesome job with the street sets too. It had to be a combination of CGI and scale sets.

This show had a special place in my heart. Growing up in NYC in that time frame. I can't believe how well they nailed the look and feel of NY in the 1970's. I felt like I could almost smell it. The clothes, cars, the music and especially the attitude. The attitude comes naturally for Keitel and Imperioli. But in that setting, it was perfect. That classic, hard nosed Brooklyn accent of days past.



reply

First let me say I Just got done watching the series on Netflix and I loved it I thought it got a proper ending...ANYWAY talking about inaccuracies I could be wrong but I think the stake out van was maybe a later 70's (as in 77,78 or 79) early 80's van because of the square headlights...That's about all I could find I wasn't really looking but I did happen to notice it...

reply

Which ep, Do you remember?

reply

A couple of songs in it didn't come out until 1974, and a reference is made to "Death Wish," which also premiered in 1974. I'm not aware that there were Russian gangsters in New York as early as 1973, although it's certainly possible that a few guys got out and decided to try their hand at capitalism.

And there were a couple of episodes that referenced events taking place in summer 1973 but there was snow on the ground. Since the last episode was right after Nixon's "I am not a crook" press conference, which was on November 17, it makes it unlikely that there was any snow in New York at the times in question. If it were Minneapolis, or even Boston, maybe, but not New York.

But the snow thing is the only serious nitpick I have, continuity-wise. A baseball player named Glenn Burke claimed he invented the high five in 1977, so Vic Tyler not knowing what it was makes sense.

reply

So far, I only watched the first episode, Out Here in the Fields, on Netflix.

There were 2 scenes of the World Trade Centers, one in daylight and one in nighttime. Both scenes showed one of the WTC towers with an antenna.

The antenna was not put up until 1978.

I sent this in as an anachronistic goof to IMDB yesterday.

reply

Good catch on the WTC..curious though..the WTC didnt exist at the time of filming so they had to make a CGI version with an antenna..hahah

*********************
Conservatives hate what people do -- Liberals hate who people are.

reply

Just watched episode 2. Here's another one:
In "The Real Adventures of the Unreal Sam Tyler," at about the 29:00 mark, while Sam is looking through the window in the precinct, Roma Torre on NY1 along with the NY1 logo can be seen. NY1 is a cable channel that did not launch until 1992.

reply

But at that point, Sam is seeing things from BOTH time periods. If he's seeing his 2008 precinct reflected, a network starting in 1992 could very well be on the screen.

reply

In one episode (I think it was My Maharishi Is Bigger Than Your Maharishi) Ray tells one of the hippies on the street, "1968 called. It wants its .... back." (I don't remember what it wanted back. An article of clothing I think.) I was born in 1973 so I don't technically remember it, but that particular saying seems like a more recent thing.

reply

You may be right about that, but you also have to remember that Ray was a jackass. Not an idiot, by any means, but a jackass. (The original British version was every bit as bad -- and Gene was worse.)

reply

I agree with okie-lady. That phrasing "19XX called. It wants its XXXX back." is fairly recent. At least I certainly don't ever remember hearing in in 1973. Not even until the 21st century actually.

reply

I remember the popular "...called and wants its...back" coming in sometime in the early to mid '90's.

**********************************************************************
SPOILER: Of course, since Ray is an extension created by Sam (at east, as I understand), it is quite possible this is not a mistake of any kind, but a hint.

reply

The Bet Ray and Sam made on the Frazier/Ali Fight was in Jan 1974, but all through the episode they are Sam keeps saying 1973.

reply

In episode 4 "Have you seen your mother, baby, standing in the shadows" at approx. 37-38 minutes when Sam and Gene are outside and you have the wide shot with them in the foreground the bridge on the left and the cityscape in the background, you can clearly see the out of focus Verizon signage of the building in the background.

reply

Yeah, caught the Verizon one too. Verizon didn't exist until 10 years later in '83.

reply