MovieChat Forums > Atonement (2008) Discussion > So Briony was jealous of Robbie that he ...

So Briony was jealous of Robbie that he wouldn't give her attention..


I think a lot of people are saying that Briony was a child who didn't understand sex. She was 13 and she was a playwright and she didn't understand human relations aka "sex"??? I learned about sex when I was about 11/12 she seemed more mature than her peers I just find it hard to believe that she didn't learn about it beforehand. I think the point is she loved Robbie, but Robbie wouldn't give her attention instead devotes his love to Cecilia, so she transforms that jealousy into hate, namely seeing the worst in everything Robbie does. That's why she assumes that Robbie is a sex predator and decided to tell on him...If I were Robbie I'd find her and hunt this b*tch down for destroying my life..

reply

Sure she knew about sex but she didn't understand it at all. Remember her talk about her play: "Love is all well and good, but you have to be sensible."
I don't think her jealousy turned to hate, not in the one afternoon of the time frame in which this all took place. Briony was quite fond of Robbie at the beginning, "Will you come see my play?" she asked him, looking nervously hopeful.
Certainly, his rejection of her after she jumped in the river a few years earlier was a factor but it was a confluence of events happening at a particular time in her life that helped her accuse Robbie.
And because the story is entirely Briony's, we don't know what the real reason was. She's about the most unreliable narrator there could be. We don't know that Robbie was remembering Briony and the river jump as he was traipsing through France. Briony put that thought in his head to give the reader a sense of motivation. I think McEwan, the real author, was showing us what a jumble it all was in Briony's head.

reply

Yes she was jealous, but that is no excuse for her behavior.

On the other hand, if Robbie and Cee had a better sense of decorum, and had gone into a room for their tryst (instead of banging against the bookcase in the library), an impressionable 13 year old girl would not have seen it, and been traumatized by it. So there was bad behavior all around.









Schrodinger's cat walks into a bar and doesn't.

reply

What's the point of you repeating this same sentiment on multiple threads? We get it. You think they should have used more "decorum".

reply