MovieChat Forums > Jane Eyre (2007) Discussion > A photo thought to be of Charlotte Bront...

A photo thought to be of Charlotte Bronte


This photo was discovered in France with "Bronte sisters" written on the back. It is thought to be of the famous sisters, although no hard evidence has been found yet.

http://www.brontesisters.co.uk/images/three.sisters.ambrotype.x600.jpg


And this is a close-up on Charlotte

http://www.brontesisters.co.uk/images/Bronte_compare_Charlote_x2a.jpg

I post this here because her features, especially her piercing eyes, remind me so much of her description of Jane Eyre in the novel. I also find it striking that both her sisters are looking at her while she's looking at the camera. I always thought of her as the leader of the three siblings, and the photo makes me think I wasn't too far off.

reply

Hi, Tomatish. 

Interestingly, the Brontë Parsonage Museum has this to say about the photograph:


This photograph, discovered by Lancashire researcher Robert Haley, 45, in a private Scottish collection, has the words 'Les soeurs Brontë, Londres,' written on the back. Could it be, as Mr Haley believes, the only photograph of the three Brontë sisters together?

Experts at Bradford's National Media Museum were dubious, dating the photograph to the 1850s, by which time two of the sisters, Emily and Anne, were already dead. And Ann Dinsdale, Collections Manager at the Parsonage Museum adds, 'We do get contacted regularly by people who have discovered images or portraits they believe may be the Brontës. The thing you have to bear in mind is, why would anyone have wanted to paint or photograph them at that time? They weren't famous and were relatively poor women. There's no reference in any surviving correspondence to a group photograph of the sisters.'

Furthermore, a comparison of the women's features with those of the portraits in existence, shows no resemblance to them. And, whereas the portaits we know show striking family similarities between the three, these three women look completely unalike.

'We would all love to know what the Brontës looked like,' adds Ann Dinsdale. Photography as a common means of portraying people was still in its infancy in the late 1840s when Emily and Anne died, though. Sadly, it is unlikely a group photograph of the three exists.






If there aren't any skeletons in a man's closet, there's probably a Bertha in his attic.

reply