MovieChat Forums > Dexter (2006) Discussion > Dexter Vs Game of thrones which had the ...

Dexter Vs Game of thrones which had the worse final season?


Dexter Season 8 was a pretty terrible final season, and the end is almost comically bad. Game of Thrones was at least equal in terms of the ending quality; maybe even worse.

For me though Game of Thrones is the worst of the 2 and impacted the show negatively much more than Dexter's last season. So much of the story of Game of Thrones depended on the ending, that since it was awful in every way it killed all rewatch value.

At least with Dexter there are multiple seasons that you can treat as 'series finale'. Season 5 and 7 are both acceptable places to stop and be satisfied. Even 2 or 3 would work. Only 4 and 6 which end on cliff hangers are the only ones that you can't really stop at.

Where with Game of Thrones there is no good place to stop before the end and the end is such a unmitigated disaster there is no re-watch value now.

reply

That sums it up well. Good analysis.

reply

Worst case with Dexter, you can watch seasons 1 to 4. The final episode in season 4 could work perfectly as a series final episode. And the first 4 seasons are excellent.

reply

I don't know if I agree. It would be hard to stop watching after season 4 ending on such a cliff hanger. Season 5 though a serious dip in quality I think is a better place to end it. You have a little more resolution for the character after the fall out of season 4.

reply

I don't share the common hate for season 5. I thought it was great. It was after S5 that his kid started being a problem for the writers. I was even sorta OK with S6 despite this. To me, S7 and S8 are equally bad and better left unwatched.

reply

I recently rewatched Season 5 and it is good; not quite as good as Season 4 but Jordan Chase is a creepy villain, also Quinn's interest in Dexter added some good tension (that was never followed up on in later seasons). Luman was kind of the weak part of the season.

I agree that in S7 and S8 they constantly didn't know how to navigate around his kid. It was like he became nothing but a plot obstacle that was only around 'occasionally' as an annoyance.

The way it should have played out in S7 and S8 was when LaGuerta became suspicious of Dexter, Quinn should have either become involved in it assisting in the investigation that would lead to Dexter's downfall; or it is revealed that he knows and has been running cover for Dexter and it is him that maybe helps Dexter escape or something like that.

reply

I wouldn't watch either of them ever again, to be honest. Well, I have no choice with GoT since the last two seasons are in my Google Play collection (I didn't know they were gonna suck then).

reply

Dexter has a lot of rewatch value. The nice thing about it is you can pretend the last season didn't happen. For example I rewatched the series up to season 5 with my wife and enjoyed it still. My preferred stopping point is Season 7; I just pretend that it ends with Debra shooting Dexter in the conex box instead of LaGuerta; it works for me.

You poor bastard, I would hate to have GoT last 2 seasons on my collection.

reply

"You poor bastard, I would hate to have GoT last 2 seasons on my collection."
Does it fall under "so bad, it's good if only for the cringe factor" so you can laugh at it?

reply

No, it is like so bad that you will want to throw something at the TV. The penultimate episode was so frustratingly dumb I had to shut it off mid episode; but the stupid had been building since the 3 episode. You will know what I mean when you see it. At least the first 2 episodes are just boring, and I mean for it being the last season and a shortened one at that the first 2 episodes frightfully little happens. Put this way, I knew we were in trouble by the end of the 2nd episode because it is like, 'great now they have to rush through everything in only 4 episodes'.

With Dexter though, the whole last season was boring and had kind of the the 'so bad it is good' cringeyness to it.

reply

Game of Thrones had the worse ending.

For one thing, Game of Thrones was the much better show known for its great writing. I was never as invested in Dexter as a show as I was Game of Thrones and so the ending to it hurt more.

Secondly, like you said, Game of Thrones was building to an ending from the start and so the poor ending undoes the rest of the show or at least its re-watch value, whereas Dexter was never building towards an ending as such and while the last season does have conclusions for characters, you can almost treat it as much as an accompaniment as a necessity.

reply


"whereas Dexter was never building towards an ending as such"

Yup, that is the key. Dexter was never building to an ultimate ending; you could see it was sort of making it up as it went after the first 2 seasons, which is why there like always a 'primary' villain each season. Game of Thrones was all about the ending. Everything in the show was about building to an ending. So for the ending to be such a incredible bust completely ruins everything that came before. It was all building towards nothing.

reply

"winter is coming" The fall lasted 5 years.

reply

I’ll still watch Dexter all the way through and would suggest it to people. No interest in rewatching GoT and will tell people not to even bother.

reply

I don't know, I would tell people to skip the last season but watch up to 7. I also tell people don't waste your time with GOT.

reply

All you need to make Dexter bearable is to to turn the TV off after he dumps Deb's body in the ocean. Then just assume he managed to get to Argentina and you have an acceptable closure. The real killer of Dexter was the ridiculous notion that he suddenly becomes a lumberjack. That kind of wander off and start a new identity crap might have worked 30 years ago but when the government pushed the ID checks for employers there was no way Dexter could just suddenly be someone else, he lacked any of the SS number or other stuff he would need to just pop up as someone else.

reply

Dexter had many victims that were single and loners. It was never stated but someone with Dexters ability coukls easly have taken several indenties. Remember he had that "escape bag" with several IDs in it.

reply

Dexter could have done as you say, except the writers eliminated that possibility when the Bay Harbor Butchers dumping ground was discovered early on and the bodies and DNA was recovered... remember they were doing DNA ID's of all the victims he had dumped there. So most of his victims that he could have taken the ID's from were now known and once known they would have gone into the system which would remove the SS they had from the active file... so now if Dexter had tried to use one of the ID's and SS numbers he would have set off red flags in an instance.

The other problem is that drivers licenses in the US require a finger print, assume he actually killed someone that looked like him and didn't dump him in the Harbor where the body was discovered. At some point he would have needed to renew that drivers license and then boom, his finger print doesn't match and the red flag pops up again.

It is simply not as easy today as it was 40 years ago to assume someones identity. He would have had a much easier time showing up in Argentina where their system is less sophisticated. Once there it would have been much easier to get a new identity.

reply

not all victims were found and there were many more after that. I have never been finger printed, Don't know where you live but I just renewed my drivers licenece and was not printed in Missouri.

reply

Game of Thrones, hands down.

reply

I rewatched (and enjoyed much more than originally) the last season of Dexter. I cannot imagine that happening with the last season of Game of Thrones.

reply

I don't think I will ever go back and rewatch or enjoy the last season of Dexter; there was just to much stupid and boring plots. And I really don't like that Psychiatrist lady that 'created' Dexter. I hate the way that undermines what Harry did. I hate that there was no real fallout for Dexter, he doesn't get caught and there is never any real suspicion; even when he is on video stabbing that guy with the pen. Batista just kind of blows it off. I also hated how Dexter was like having 'puppy love' with Hannah and became a stupid person over it, he couldn't even stalk people correctly anymore. The suggestion that romantic love is a cure for psychopathy is just ridiculous.

That being said, it is still no where near as bad as the last season of GOT, and I can still watch up to season 7 of Dexter and enjoy it. I agree with you on GOT, but also I say that the last season of GOT was so bad it killed all rewatch value for the whole series. I will never go back and rewatch any of the series ever again, and I will not watch any new shows that come out in that franchise. which is really saying something, because I truly loved the show even more than Dexter.

reply

Well, I can imagine rewatching the last season of GOT at some point, I just can't imagine enjoying it.

reply

I don't think I could ever subject myself to watching any of GOT every again; everything I enjoyed about it was completely and utterly ruined by the last season. All the build up was for nothing. With Dexter it wasn't all building to a finale; it season was self contained enough that it doesn't depend on how it ends.

reply

This is a great topic! Let me put it this way...right now I'm rewatching Dexter, yes I already know that it ends terribly, but it is still watchable. As for GoT, I have no desire to ever watch it again knowing that it has such a terrible and anticlimactic ending. To me, the ending there destroyed anything great that show ever did.

reply

yup, that is the real issue with; the show Dexter was not a constant build up to its finale; each season is almost independent and can be watched stand alone. GOT was show that from the frist episode was building towards the end. Now becuase the built up lead to such an unbelievable terrible finale not only does the show have zero rewatch value, it also effectively destroyed any interest in the universe. I have no interest in any other GOT content. I won't be watching the spin off series, no video games, no more side books. The only thing I will do it finish the main series novels (if Martin ever finishes them) just to see if Martin ends the series better. But then that is it; I will be done with GOT content. Which is amazing because I have been invested in this series since 2010; I read all the books just before the series came out. It was a deep 10 year investment that now has been burned away. For the end to be so bad that it just killed all interest is really saying something.

reply

That's exactly it! I've actually never had that happen with a TV show. But you're right, GoT was all about that ending from the very beginning and every one of the audience was waiting for that ending. Maybe it was hype and in doing so it couldn't help but be a let down...but that ending for me blew the entire thing and I never want to lay eyes on it again.

reply

The only other show that had such a build up to the finale was Breaking Bad; but where GOT failed, Breaking Bad excelled. The ending of that show was perfect and the last season was arguably the best of the series; or close to it.

The hype about the ending might have contributed to the unrealistic expectations and backlash when the expectations were not met; but then why was Breaking Bad so satisfying, it had a pretty close to equal amount of hype (maybe not to the scale of GOT). That is because Breaking Bad understood what ending it was building towards and just told its story in a logical fashion. There was no goal of 'subverting expectations' like with GOT. and every payoff of breaking bad had proper build up; nothing happened that you can say 'couldn't have been expected'. That was the problem with GOT, they were trying too hard to make the audience go 'wow, I wasn't expecting that' and that came at the cost of coherent story telling.

But the difference in how the 2 shows ended makes a big difference; I can't get enough of the Breaking Bad universe still; even with Dexter I would poke my head in on to see additional material if it came out. I would be absolutely unwilling to set through any GOT content. it has been over a year and I have not been able to go back and watch a single episode. I unsubscribed from a bunch of my favorite youtube GOT channels, just because I was so disgusted by the end and so unwilling to listen to anymore content. 5 years ago I would not have believed that was even possible.

reply

I'm definitely with you once again. Breaking Bad had a great final season and an unforgettable series finale. I recently rewatched Breaking Bad beginning to end and still loved it. I'm rewatching Dexter right now as well, Season 4 is ending as I type this. For the most part, as I've already said, I still find these early seasons of Dexter enjoyable to watch and it still fills me with a sense of dread that I can't stop watching, which for me, still makes it okay television.

And I'll say it again, what GoT did to it's audience in that final season is unforgiveable. I will never be able to recommend it to anyone for "good television viewing."

reply

Dexter is bearable for me until season 8. But the nice thing is season 7 feels like a satisfying conclusion; especially if you can pretend Deb shoots Dexter in the season 7 finale instead of Legurta. It is a perfect ending right there. The story and character are resolved enough that either season 5 or season 7 can 'work' as an ending. Unfortunately that cannot be done for GoT. No season can serve as a satisfying conclusion; the story depended on the last season to complete it and it was a fucking disaster.

Exactly true; the end was a lazy big old F' You. I think they just did not plan on not having the books to rely on and couldn't fill in the gaps on their own and wanted to check out as soon as possible and didn't give 2 shits about the fans or the quality of their writing; just solve it all as fast as possible was the mentality. I too will never recommend the show to anyone. I have been asked and I tell people, "don't waste you time, you will not be happy with it". I think around 15 people I have told that to that I know will now never watch the show; or any of its Bullshit spin offs. I hope House of the Dragon goes up in flames (if it every actually reaches the screens).

reply

shows with alot of hype like Dexter and got....True Blood was the worse final season.

reply