Anti-Hazara comments


I just wanted to bring this into the attention of the audience that there are some "anti-hazara" comments in the film. The driver explains how Hazaras "torture" people. These people have been historically denied rights and representation due to thier religion (Shi'a Islam) and their physical Characteristics. "Kite Runner" is a good example of this prejudice.

The funny thing is that the characters who are playing Hazaras don't even look anything like them. Bad Casting! Also- the director fell prey of this "prejudice."

Your comments are welcome!

----
"Life is a suspense film, its only watched once." -Unknown

reply

yeah... they looked nothing like Hazaras

reply

I agree, everyone should read The Kiterunner to get a lot of non biased info on the Hazaras. It's a great book.

reply

[deleted]

Yes, I do not understand why the hostility towards the hazara people had to be said by Khyber (their guide and driver)?? And yes it added even more insult to injury when it turned out that the guards at the next check point which they were referring to weren't even Hazara. So, what was the point of this judgement made about the hazara's?
"These people have been historically denied rights and representation due to thier religion (Shi'a Islam) and their physical Characteristics. "Kite Runner" is a good example of this prejudice." This is an extremely good point! Though, I was born in Kabul and both my parents are as they say "Kabuli," I have some what Asiatic feauturs that make me look more like a Hazara, and I got alot of grief from friends and family, growing up partly in Pakistan, alot of people would make a remark about my features and make fun of me. I never understood why. All I know is that I thought it was extremely unfair and totally irrational.
I suppose most of the hostility comes from the fact that they have chosen to follow a differnt sect of Islam...

reply

Thank God the government banned it!

http://www.businessofcinema.com/2007/8jan/kabul_express.htm

----
"Life is a suspense film, its only watched once." -MZK

reply

This is totally ridicules, I am not agreeing for what government did and what people did against this movie. Come on guys this is a movie and when government announces democracy they should meant it. Then what democracy means? In India and lots of other countries in the movies even they say lots of bad words about the government it self, but no one make this much scene out of it. It is really shameful for a democratic government to stop a movie and media for just a simple comment. If they say those words about Hazara they have mentioned lots of words about Pashton people to, but no one said anything from Pashton ethic, and to be honest it was not something lie, it was a reality we don’t say this for all Hazara people but there were some Hazara people who killed other in a very bad way. Everybody know this how they killed women with their small children. This is not only saying this is proved by videos and pictures. I really don’t have anything with my Afghan people if they are Hazara Pashton or Tajic, but this is really idiot that people go for a big demonstration for just a movie. This really shows poor education and thinking power.

reply

[deleted]

Sentences used in the film against Hazara's are unacceptable. This film is against whole Afghan people. Hazara's make upto 29% of Afghan population. Both the film director and writer have been used by other ethnic groups in Afghanistan, like Tajiks who make up 9% of afghan population. I wonder how such big names have been used so cheaply. This is a matter of shame for Bollywood who's legends are such thick minded.
When Hazaras are taking part in the contructions of Aghanistan the neighbour countries should take part in a positive way rathar than escalating the situation of war torn Afghan people.

reply

i am so disgusted to watch that part of movie where hazaras are portryed as bloody eliens. i am glad that the movie is banned in afghanistan, hazaras are minority groups who always have been tortured by bloody pashtoons and tajiks. hazaras were the first target for taliban who are pashtoons. thats why so many hazaras fled out of country, pashtoons are the none sense people who got greed in there bottoms. they are ignorant and jahil thats why the outsiders made then donkey and all of them became wahabi and taliban.
the anti shia and anti hazara amongst pashtoon and taliban is at highest degree that they killed hundreds of hazaras in quetta pakistan when they were perfoming aashura. same year they killed hundreds in mosques.
they also killed hazara great leader mazari. taliban first took of his skin. burned him. and take photos of him while he was dead and post it on every street in kabul.
i am not sure why kabir did it. may be he is one of those bl pashtoon?
this movie must be bycouted and hazaras must take them to court.

reply

Out of such a curiosity I was waiting for the movie KABUL EXPRESS,But when I watched this movie ,It really shocked me ,When I saw how they discreminated Hazara ethnic group and characterized them as an evil image in the movie.But as a matter of fact 65% of Hazara people has been genocide since the reign of king Abdul Rahman Khan till the fall of Taliban,Before the offence against the Hazara people were through different ways like mass killing ,abuse ,treating them as low class afghan citizens ,since its believed that Hazaras came with the army of Genghis Khan,Today we are observing that Hazaras are being discriminated through different means ,And a very good example is the movie Kabul Express,Now one must think who should be blamed for this discremination ,Bollywood and Hazaras,what they have to do with eachother,though I'm pretty sure that at least hundred thousands of Hazara s watch bollywood movies all over the world,For a while I was thinking and trying to figure out ,then I came to the conclusion that we still have evil elements active in the capital Kabul,who guided these movie makers how to make ur script,And those evil elements knew that what exaclty they are trying to show ,My point is towards Kabir Khan as well ,whose backround is obviously pashtoon ,An old rival for Hazara Mughuls,And few other culprits who played a major role while making this movie ,which I must say is baseless and has got nothing to do with Hazaras ,Though all those made up stories against Hazaras directly applies to Pashtoons who are famous of human trafficing and sending illegal cars across the borders of Afghanistan,SO in the end I must say the movie really disappointed me ,And I guess bollywood movies are good to watch when they make love stories,because it keeps those people entertained who live in a world of fantasy ,Alp ranges of Switzerland where we see bollywood actors running back and fourth .

reply

Out of such a curiosity I was waiting for the movie KABUL EXPRESS,But when I watched this movie ,It really shocked me ,When I saw how they discriminated Hazara ethnic group and characterized them as an evil image in the movie.But as a matter of fact 65% of Hazara people has been genocide since the reign of king Abdul Rahman Khan till the fall of Taliban,Before the offence against the Hazara people were through different ways like mass killing ,abuse ,treating them as low class afghan citizens ,since its believed that Hazaras came with the army of Genghis Khan,Today we are observing that Hazaras are being discriminated through different means ,And a very good example is the movie Kabul Express,Now one must think who should be blamed for this discrimination ,Bollywood and Hazaras,what they have to do with eachother,though I'm pretty sure that at least hundred thousands of Hazara s watch bollywood movies all over the world,For a while I was thinking and trying to figure out ,then I came to the conclusion that we still have evil elements active in the capital Kabul,who guided these movie makers how to make ur script,And those evil elements knew that what exaclty they are trying to show ,My point is towards Kabir Khan as well ,whose backround is obviously pashtoon ,An old rival for Hazara Mughuls,And few other culprits who played a major role while making this movie ,which I must say is baseless and has got nothing to do with Hazaras ,Though all those made up stories against Hazaras directly applies to Pashtoons who are well known for human trafficing and sending illegal cars across the borders of Afghanistan,So in the end I must say the movie really disappointed me ,And I guess bollywood movies are good to watch when they make love stories,because it keeps those people entertained who live in a world of fantasys ,Alpes ranges of Switzerland where we see bollywood actors running back and fourth ,

reply

why do you think the whole world is against you? maybe this movie is just that, a movie??

do you really believe the time machine in krish existed?

reply

btw the film got banned in Kabul!


Some ppl can be soo fu cking ignorant.. I mean *beep* a s s Kabir Khan should make film on India's poverty before making a film on another nation which he knows nothing of!

reply

this movie isnt for u dweeb zohrah. ur comments show just how much broad minded u urself are for takin it so personally.

yes maybe the hazara comments are totally out of order but guys lets not forget Khan only showed what he went through when he was in Adghanistan. at that time there was a tendency among ppl to snub hazara cuz of their "mysterious" ways. cmon!

reply

zohrah tats f u c k i n g ignorance on ur part too hes just trying to portray the post taliban scenario and how does poverty of india comes in between...ok u ve the right to speak coz after 2015 it wont be there to be talked and mocked about

reply

[deleted]

Now before I post, let me say that I have no prior knowledge about the Hazaras.

That being said, I'm wondering...is it possible that the director is portraying the Hazaras from a certain group's point of view (for example, the Afghans?). As I said, I have no knowledge about the Hazaras, and the conflict...I threw Afghans out there as an example, no stereotypes meant.

reply

for crying out loud, its a movie, its a movie, and unfortunately, the Hazara race was used to be the "evil" ones, even if they are good or bad people, that is not the question, the question is about the fact that it was a movie and the sequence of that part needed "evil" in which Hazaras were used.

In many Bollywood/hollywood movies, there are races that are announced as evil, many anti terrorist movies have Middle eastern men playing the terrorist from Irag, Syria etc. Now should the Iraqi or Syrian government rise and banned the movie and go on strike etc. Come on!! its just immature. I have seen many movies that actually say unjust words to some races so should them races start crying?

its a movie people, and until the Afghan ppl regardless which race it is, Pashtun, Tajik, Hazara, need to be open minded and think properly, because there are and have been so many worse movies that portray so many races poorly then this Kabul Express movie!!

reply

[deleted]