MovieChat Forums > Brothers (2009) Discussion > Lazy and cowardly writing

Lazy and cowardly writing


The acting was okay, but the writing was cowardly and lazy.

Cowardly in the sense that it doesn't deal with the hard parts, whenever there's a part of the dialogue that is hard to convey realistically, it just cuts away to another scene. Wtf is up with that? I want to hear what they say, I want to see how they deal with stuff. But, no, instead they just cut. I could do a movie script like that, too; if I just avoid the difficult parts.

And lazy in the sense that 50% of the drama is derived from Tommy's inability to just simply say “No, Sam, I didn't fuck Grace”. I mean, realistically in life, this movie would never happen. It's like the lazy writing in comedy TV sitcoms where all the action is a product of some stupid lack of communication that would only ever happen to dumb, emotionally immature 14 year olds. I mean, he didn't have sex with Grace, so why couldn't he just say that? He would not be lying. Sam had PTS from the war, sure; but anyone else mentally unstable or not would have thought Tommy had indeed had sex with Grace when he went to so many lengths to just avoid answering a simple question.

There's also the whole deal with the father, and whatever crime Tommy committed that don't lead anywhere.

Overall, a very disappointing movie, that had some potential but couldn't be arsed to put in the effort.

reply